Just wondering if a Q&A sub forum is really needed? The General forum is already being almost exclusively used for Q&A, and people are reposting a lot of questions here that have already been asked and answered in the General...
Nirvana388 said:
Just wondering if a Q&A sub forum is really needed? The General forum is already being almost exclusively used for Q&A, and people are reposting a lot of questions here that have already been asked and answered in the General...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm not sure, but according to the title of this forum, you're not supposed to post any questions to the other Forum. I don't know how useful it will be if people are limited to posting tips only there.
One good thing about this forum is that because the volume is smaller (for the moment) your posts are closer to the top and thus, easier to find.
Nirvana388 said:
Just wondering if a Q&A sub forum is really needed? The General forum is already being almost exclusively used for Q&A, and people are reposting a lot of questions here that have already been asked and answered in the General...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
i was asking myself the same thing the first day when they created it.
it's redundant to General forum
almost anyone posting will begin with a question, in the end General will become obsolete, and everyone will be using Q&A instead
maybe, but if this sticks to questions only, i like it
Related
Hey. This is an open ended question to prompt discussion here. Not to flame / attack anyone.
Firstly thankyou for the q+a section - invaluable resourse.
My question is this. On several occasions I have seen threads deleted / moved / closed with the explanation of "wrong sub forum". That's it. I realise that modding is difficult. But surely to learn we need to know what's wrong with where we post not just that it is wrong.
One recent example is a thread asking about developing a piece of software to simplify sdcard splitting.
I would have thought development was the right place but the thread was closed and told that it was the wrong place. So, what defines development from q+a? If I have a question about development then should I post in both forums as it is development and a question?
Development is just that - DEVELOPMENT. Questions should NOT be asked there. Questions are to be asked here. No matter what kind of questions they are.
ok, that sounds sensible
milestone.it said:
ok, that sounds sensible
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Lol yesterday the entire front page of the development section was locked because ignorant people were posting questions when there is CLEARLY a Q&A section. Some of us camp out here to help people...Who ever said you're never going to get help in this section.
whats the fastest and most stable rom that also has 2.1 firmware for live wallpapes
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=668090
Out of the three threads you've created, g1man, not one of them has been in the right section. :l
then were should i put them
lets see, you just asked a question so maybe you should try the g1 Q&A forum (question & answer)
This here is development, your QUESTION in no way has anything to do with developing anything for the HTC dream
well, considering you are asking QUESTIONS, they should really go in that lovely place called the QUESTIONS and ANSWERS section....
Tagged to end the flaming. Please read the rules BEFORE posting. Thanks.
There is also a nice sticky thread for your needs, he has reviewed all roms and given them ratings for your needs
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=668090
Moving this to Q&A.
WB
I don't mean to be an ass here, but I, for one, would be happy to post all my questions in the Q&A section...but looking over there at the numerous questions on just the first page there are probably less than 100 replies, cummulatively, for all those questions. I've posted over there a couple of times and never got an answer from a Dev (the ones that could answer).
So, would you wiz dev and pro scripters please go over there every once and while and answer some questions, please! It would certainly help keep your forum more clean, which I agree, is out of control.
If you ask in the dev's original thread, you often do get an answer and keep from poluting the dev forums.
I'm just going to say it. This belongs in Q & A.
Most of the questions people ask are thread specific. If they would just read the thread that pertains to the question chances are it will be discussed in that thread. Now if it is a question that has not been talked about in their dev thread ask the question and they will respond. These guys have lives and are not solely on XDA 24/7
flashman2002 said:
I'm just going to say it. This belongs in Q & A.
Most of the questions people ask are thread specific. If they would just read the thread that pertains to the question chances are it will be discussed in that thread. Now if it is a question that has not been talked about in their dev thread ask the question and they will respond. These guys have lives and are not solely on XDA 24/7
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
+1
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I897 using XDA App
flashman2002 said:
I'm just going to say it. This belongs in Q & A.
Most of the questions people ask are thread specific. If they would just read the thread that pertains to the question chances are it will be discussed in that thread. Now if it is a question that has not been talked about in their dev thread ask the question and they will respond. These guys have lives and are not solely on XDA 24/7
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
kletiz said:
+1
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I897 using XDA App
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
+2
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I897 using XDA App
The "Search this thread" option above the thread actually works pretty well. For those of us who can't read 300+ pages of threads looking for an answer.
boomerod said:
So, would you wiz dev and pro scripters please go over there every once and while and answer some questions, please! It would certainly help keep your forum more clean, which I agree, is out of control.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I agree, that's why some members keep asking on DEV section. No buddy you're not being an ass I understand your frustration.
As someone else stated, if you have a question about a specific thread in the dev forum, then ask it in that thread. Also try the "Search This Thread" option to see if your question has already been asked/answered.
I know some of those threads grow like crazy, but that's where those questions belong.
The devs do this work on their own free time and only get some donations from members. Most of the time I think they mainly monitor their thread or try to help out in other dev threads.
If someone in the community knows the answer and checks that section, then I'm sure they'll point you in the right direction too.
As a mod, I'm trying to keep the dev forum a little cleaner by moving stuff out of there...and IMO, having a General forum and a Q&A forum is a little redundant because lots of stuff in the general forum turns into questions.
I'm wondering, is it really that hard to post in the correct section? Here are some threads that should be in Q&A, but all were on the first page in General when I copied their links:
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1994709
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1994691
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1990224
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1994362
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1978458
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1993701
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1989239
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1986175
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1990041
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1987624
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1989328
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1989000
That is 12 out of 20 threads (the stickied ones were not included) on the first page that weren't posted where they should be.
Also, I noticed that most of these threads were started by people with none to very few posts... Connection?
I sense that this thread might get closed for some reason.
The threads that I linked to should be closed/moved, or the newbies (mostly, some senior members as well..) who haven't yet developed the ability to read will soon post every single question they have in General...
My suggestion is increasing the post requirement before you can post in General.
A. Volunteer to become a moderator and hand down infractions or use the report post button.
B. Do you think you have any sort of authority over others and or think you are perfect?
C. Do you realize that your whiny post HAS NO PLACE HERE? (As does my response)
neovdr said:
A. Volunteer to become a moderator and hand down infractions or use the report post button.
B. Do you think you have any sort of authority over others and or think you are perfect?
C. Do you realize that your whiny post HAS NO PLACE HERE? (As does my response)
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
B: The OP is correct, the Q&A question exists for question, this one for general discussions. Where did he say he's perfect or above others?
C: Why not? He has a fair point. And I don't see him whining. What is your problem?
But I don't agree: Raising the post count for the General section is not a solution.
Maybe a new closed stickyied thread "This section is NOT for Questions you have, use Q&A for that" might help.
Reported my own post and suggested it to the mods.
Cheers.
tonyp said:
B: The OP is correct, the Q&A question exists for question, this one for general discussions. Where did he say he's perfect or above others?
C: Why not? He has a fair point. And I don't see him whining. What is your problem?
But I don't agree: Raising the post count for the General section is not a solution.
Maybe a new closed stickyied thread "This section is NOT for Questions you have, use Q&A for that" might help.
Reported my own post and suggested it to the mods.
Cheers.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Because the Q&A section is a no-man's land where no dev ever ventures. Trying to push the new guys that come here to the fringes is not the solution.
neovdr said:
Because the Q&A section is a no-man's land where no dev ever ventures. Trying to push the new guys that come here to the fringes is not the solution.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Apart from the fact that I and a couple others in fact ARE scanning the q&a section every now and then for questions which are lacking an answer and are not covered in any of the other threads:
That's not a valid reason to post in the wrong section. Especially considering the kind of questions linked in the OP which are pretty often already covered multiple times all over xda.
Sent from my Nexus 7 using xda app-developers app
neovdr said:
Because the Q&A section is a no-man's land where no dev ever ventures. Trying to push the new guys that come here to the fringes is not the solution.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
you're wrong they answer the questions that never been asked before if your question doesn't answer so search it first before creating a new thread if you search for an hour so search for a day and if you can't find it and you search for almost a day that's the right time to post don't post anything because you only want to reach 10 post to be able to post in developers section
Sent from my LG-P990 using xda premium
grimmyrippy said:
you're wrong they answer the questions that never been asked before if your question doesn't answer so search it first before creating a new thread if you search for an hour so search for a day and if you can't find it and you search for almost a day that's the right time to post don't post anything because you only want to reach 10 post to be able to post in developers section
Sent from my LG-P990 using xda premium
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The thing is when I go into the Q&A and see a bunch of old threads I am gonna think like that. I didn't talk out of my ass but went to the section and that was what compelled me to answer. The problems of this forum imo are solved with active moderation. Things like warnings, thread deletions and relocations. Until that investment is made we will be suffering this kind of problems.
can some one post results of a speed test with at&t hspa+ or if they even remotely got any lte?
Hi teamHTC,
Your thread has been moved from Xperia Z1 General to Xperia Z1 Q&A, Help & Troubleshooting. Please post in the correct sub-forum in future.
--wedgess
Forum Moderator
Do you ever search before posting? Also, this question could have been asked in your original thread that again you didn't search before posting. Not many threads in the Z1 subforum, not that hard.
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=2459611
QwaarJet said:
Do you ever search before posting? Also, this question could have been asked in your original thread that again you didn't search before posting. Not many threads in the Z1 subforum, not that hard.
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=2459611
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I think the op should get banned or a warning at the very least! He always makes new threads even though there is already an open thread with his question.
uly609 said:
I think the op should get banned or a warning at the very least! He always makes new threads even though there is already an open thread with his question.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
damn, you guys are really rude. I am just asking a few questions.. its not like this forum could use a few more threads anyway. thanks for your help.
teamHTC said:
damn, you guys are really rude. I am just asking a few questions.. its not like this forum could use a few more threads anyway. thanks for your help.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I would agree with you if the threads didn't already exist. it is pointless to have multiple threads on the same topic. kthanks.