Google Assistant - OnePlus 3T Questions & Answers

Hey guys,
Tried out several ROMs/kernals, etc....mostly looking for best battery life...have found that Resurrection Remix (CM14.1) has been the best so far...
Question - in my flip flopping of ROMs I've grown to like the google assistant. Anyone have any luck installing that? I've tried editing my build.prop and installing the latest arm-64 apk beta for the google app...nothing seems to work. Anyone have any success? Oh - and if it matters - I'm using Nova Lancher beta 5.10.
Thanks in advance!

There's an xposed module that enables it....
Look for assistant enabler..
It works for me on stock rom 3.5.4

TimFlex said:
There's an xposed module that enables it....
Look for assistant enabler..
It works for me on stock rom 3.5.4
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thank you for the response...yes, that was one of the older versions I was running...anything 6.0 you can run xposed....Xposed does not have a working version for Nougat yet.

I could always get the Google assistant on a Nougat ROM. Don't remember if I tried it on RR, but I think you'll get it, just follow some guide on enabling assistant. Mine involved making those changes to build prop file, clearing cache of the Google app. Once, I could enable the assistant following a guide on XDA itself which made me flash some files. It basically does the similar editing of the build prop file. The guide was titled something like Pixel experience, maybe.
Sorry for this vagueness.
The point I'm trying to make is, most of the guides out there work. You just need to Google it.

Related

ZUK Z1 Custom ROMs

Hi Guys:
I found some ZUK Z1 ROMS on Chinese websites want to share with u guys, please note that i'm not developer of these ROM all credit goes to Chinese developers .Please use them at your own risk..
All ROM contain English Language
You can flash all these ROM with Breadcrust TWRP
Bliss POP:
https://mega.nz/#!qUFjWYaI!PtXgUZnK6H0ardcCt6CHZkz78UTX2psoFfSYK5IN2Fc
Carbon:
https://mega.nz/#!bddwRApb!NJsKIdBvo84cDHiyxuQ3KQ-Ix-cXc6hWFWbw9lWd5kM
Resurrection ROM
https://mega.nz/#!3VEWmBwQ!bXhlo3xmFLNdAZ2nDCwwB5y35DDBRwq095lfv4nZGXg
Zui 1.2.040: Rooted image (Please note this flash will change your custom recovery to some Chinese recovery Please flash Breads TWRP with Flashify when u boot)
https://mega.nz/#!KRFGTJ4D!ehWxlCj-zUZuSNpfES4KblfoOs3k_p90eRwY1ksR7ro
FlyMe OS:
https://mega.nz/#!PU8VBQBC!DH5hT1Y7f1bQaA45MWpKkIaBsQYfbNC04D-eazbTPSM
Lewa OS:
https://mega.nz/#!vI9y3aBB!SLD84bwahHrL4rLGmki_RpN0a0UODmseGguWa7JNgRA
ZUI version 1.2.04 Non rooted:
https://mega.nz/#!qF1lyJpJ!nKzI1dxnno6dy6X-2zlTctW7VngC69mjgTphrEiswTo
Play Store on ZUI:
https://mega.nz/#!bENBFbZb!NsiMyzZQit_oXkmRZn-9jT_Z37RVCYZNC-FmCmC7NrM
After installing above play store apk open Youtube app it will prompt to download Google services download these services .
PAC ROM
https://mega.nz/#!7BlxFSwB!72KQSzBlbCqTIwfWiNH2mWfPYStU4rHhxOPRfcBHMh8
Bliss, carbon and resurrection is all cm based and aint chinese in any way (correct me if im wrong) so you might want to split those up into its own section perhaps? (just to clarify the confusion for some) Zui, flyme and lewa on the other hand is chinese all the way
tndb said:
Bliss, carbon and resurrection is all cm based and aint chinese in any way (correct me if im wrong) so you might want to split those up into its own section perhaps? (just to clarify the confusion for some) Zui, flyme and lewa on the other hand is chinese all the way
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes they are CM based but develop by Chinese developers ,
grengo said:
Yes they are CM based but develop by Chinese developers ,
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Carbon developers dont have chinese name or dont look that chinese to me?
http://carbonrom.org/the-team/
No pics on bliss or ressurection but highly doubt they are chinese devs
tndb said:
Carbon developers dont have chinese name or dont look that chinese to me?
http://carbonrom.org/the-team/
No pics on bliss or ressurection but highly doubt they are chinese devs
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It's not about whether the ROM developers are Chinese or not but rather the device tree author / builder / porter.
MrColdbird said:
It's not about whether the ROM developers are Chinese or not but rather the device tree author / builder / porter.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hm ok, never thought any of those had chinese "influence" or however you describe it. Not that it matters for me though but just another one of those unnecessary facts. You learn something every day as they say :good:
Sorry for the slight semi offtopic-ness
@grengo Thanks for bring this roms here , which rom you prefer ?
Anyone tried any ROM?
I tried resurrection rom. it's good.
Hi
How is the resurrection ROM mobile signal,GPS, finger print??? Did you feel it's better than Cynogen??
I'm not feeling any different, GPS not tested.
rom more customization..
I will keep two days after that I'll try carbon rom
Now with a twrp image of zui, I gave it a whirl and my impressions are its quite nice, camera app is good, overall speed and responsiveness is awesome and better than COS. It needs some adjustments here n there but im gonna try and make a tweaked rom out of it without chinese apps and integrate google apps. Had problem with capacitive buttons being disabled and it was only the fingerprint button that worked with swiping, touch and push. Would like to know how to enable those. Wifi wasnt working either for me but I guess you need to flash the whole zui factory image first with qpst for it to work unless someone else has an idea?
I gave lewa OS a try aswell after this but wasnt anything for me, that was just cm12 + a skin ontop basicly so naturally wifi worked since I was originally coming from C.OS
@tndb Wifi is working for me i don't know why it is not working for U...
for on screen button you can edit build.prop file by adding some lines (Google it)
For play store on ZUI download below Play store apk, then open Youtube app it will ask for Google play services download these services..
Link for play store on ZUI:
https://mega.nz/#!bENBFbZb!NsiMyzZQit_oXkmRZn-9jT_Z37RVCYZNC-FmCmC7NrM
PAC rom:
https://mega.nz/#!7BlxFSwB!72KQSzBlbCqTIwfWiNH2mWfPYStU4rHhxOPRfcBHMh8
what the problem with FlyMe OS link not working.
@gamal001 link updated
FlyMe is good ?
grengo said:
@tndb Wifi is working for me i don't know why it is not working for U...
for on screen button you can edit build.prop file by adding some lines (Google it)
For play store on ZUI download below Play store apk, then open Youtube app it will ask for Google play services download these services..
Link for play store on ZUI:
https://mega.nz/#!bENBFbZb!NsiMyzZQit_oXkmRZn-9jT_Z37RVCYZNC-FmCmC7NrM
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hey and thanks for your notes. I still cant get wifi working, tried reflashing but nothing, have you just flashed zui through twrp coming from Cyanogen without flashing zui through qpst first?
Regarding the capacitive buttons, they wont work either. Tried adding qemu.hw.mainkeys=1 to build.prop and also ro.mot.buttonlight.timeout=0 to see if the leds would turn on but they are not working at all. Its only the middle button working.
Ive made a tweaked rom out of the zui twrp package you posted where ive removed a bunch of china apps, changed default language to english and country to US, replaced default launcher with nova launcher, integrated google play, ive also replaced the built-in recovery with breadcrust twrp.
If I could just find out why WIFI aint turning on, the toggle is deactivated and when I press it, its not moving at all. If I restore my twrp Cyanogen OS backup then wifi works just fine again but not at all on Zui. Ive seen this on other phone models when they didnt have the correct modem for example but not sure where id get a suitable one for that (if this even is the problem) and manage to activate the capacitive buttons would also be of great help
Ok had some time over this night and found a solution to get wifi working in zui. Downloaded qpst and flashed zui the official way removing all data on phone and getting all stock factory stuff in there.
Perhaps its the modem file which is the problem? Not sure how to just flash that one separately to find the cause of this issue but could be worth a try
Hi, is the fingerprint sensor working nicely with these roms?

Enable Google Assistant on N5

So, i found a method to turn our Nexus 5 into a Pixel phone and enable the Google Assistant. Read everything before doing anything!
The link to the post is here: http://forum.xda-developers.com/and...-assistant-t3477879/post69074667#post69074667
Instructions:
Download 3 zip files linked in the post. Flash the Velvet zip through TWRP first. Next one is the edited build.prop zip. Make sure the tweak.prop is in the same folder/directory as the other 2 files!!!
The tweak.prop is not for flashing. Just keep it in the same folder. After you flashed the other two, simply reboot and go to Settings>Apps>Google App>Storage>Clear all Data. Go back to your homescreen and make sure you had now on tap activated. Press the home button longer so Now-on-Tap plays its animation and what you should get instead of Google Now is the Assistant saying Hello to you!
Known Issues:
Ok, Google recognition.
Thats it. My first thread so im open for questions.
This Method is not by me!!! Im just sharing it .All credits go to FaserF.
I'm running it on pure nexus 7.0.. Its pretty sweet. Its like the siri we never had lol. Not as wide of conversation range as siri, but I'm sure that gets updated with time.
ourangashane said:
I'm running it on pure nexus 7.0.. Its pretty sweet. Its like the siri we never had lol. Not as wide of conversation range as siri, but I'm sure that gets updated with time.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
How are you running pure nexus 7 on the nexus 5 ? I thought purenexus was discontinued for our device.
Vanilla Pudding said:
How are you running pure nexus 7 on the nexus 5 ? I thought purenexus was discontinued for our device.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Its an unofficial build, its in the android dev section
Can confirm working on CleanAOSP
Ok Google detection setting FCs, as said in the OP
!n0x said:
Can confirm working on CleanAOSP
Ok Google detection setting FCs, as said in the OP
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Which Android Version? Marshmallow?
N-ify my Nexus 5 running 6.0.1 with Nova Launcher, Xposed N-ify + Google Assistant and Softkeyz app for Pixel nav bar
Rezei said:
Which Android Version? Marshmallow?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Nougat
Weird bug: Every time i say "OK Google" it wants to relearn my voice. Is anyone else experiencing this issue?
meatwad0222 said:
Weird bug: Every time i say "OK Google" it wants to relearn my voice. Is anyone else experiencing this issue?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Its a known bug and no way to fix it yet.
Rezei said:
Its a known bug and no way to fix it yet.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
thank you
meatwad0222 said:
Weird bug: Every time i say "OK Google" it wants to relearn my voice. Is anyone else experiencing this issue?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Rezei said:
Its a known bug and no way to fix it yet.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
There is no fix for it, but you can automate the "skip" process with tasker. There is a post with images and another one with a text description on [this thread page](http://forum.xda-developers.com/and...ow-to-enable-google-assistant-t3477879/page40)
It works pretty well though saying "ok google" for a followup question starts the assistant over and loses it's context. Hopefully someone will get this fixed soon.
not able to flash second file
It's easy to enable google assistant using Build.prop by changing ro.product.model=Pixel XL and add this at the end:
ro.opa.eligible_device=true.
But anyway thanks for your thread
https://youtu.be/f2_P4mcMTN0
Sent from my SM-G925F using Tapatalk
fadi.cell said:
It's easy to enable google assistant using Build.prop by changing ro.product.model=Pixel XL and add this at the end:
ro.opa.eligible_device=true.
But anyway thanks for your thread
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
better yet, as you're rooted and if you have the latest xposed framework (v87) and xposed installer (v3.1.1) simply download and install the "assistant enabler (v3.1)" module, activate and reboot. it's much cleaner and easy to uninstall if you so choose; and "ok google" command works perfectly.
edit: xposed is not available for Android N (nougat).
the xposed module that allows for "google assistant" is on marshmallow.
i'm currently running this on cm13 latest nightly on an lg g3 d850 without any problems.
vakkah said:
better yet, as you're rooted and if you have the latest xposed framework (v87) and xposed installer (v3.1.1) simply download and install the "assistant enabler (v3.1)" module, activate and reboot. it's much cleaner and easy to uninstall if you so choose; and "ok google" command works perfectly.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Is xposed framework available on nougat? Can you please share its link?
gargyagotra said:
Is xposed framework available on nougat? Can you please share its link?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
no, its not available for nougat. please use google.
Rezei said:
no, its not available for nougat. please use google.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That's what I know as well..but the above comment confused me..coz GA will work on nougat only...and the guy was suggesting to install xposed module to skip the Google now training model bug
gargyagotra said:
That's what I know as well..but the above comment confused me..coz GA will work on nougat only...and the guy was suggesting to install xposed module to skip the Google now training model bug
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
He was talking about xposed for M.

Google phone/dialer app for Moto G5+

Hi,
i am perfectly fine with stock ROM and only one thing i would like to have beside. And it is Google phone app with capability to do search nearby places right from the phone app and the capability to see who actually calling behind unknown number.
I see some apks on apkmirror, but latest nonnexus apk is from 2016. So i rather ask here first. Do you guys tried this app and can confirm it has all the features i would like to have? Is it possible to have this app on our phone?
Do you have link to app for our device?
Thank you
https://www.apkmirror.com/uploads/?q=google-phone
I pulled this from OpenGapps. Flash the following Google dialer framework in TWRP and install it from the playstore... All the features work for me.
atrac17 said:
I pulled this from OpenGapps. Flash the following Google dialer framework in TWRP and install it from the playstore... All the features work for me.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Tried this without success. Running lineageos 8.0.
edit2: actually it doesn't work. Givs me a device not supported error
HatchetJackk said:
Tried this without success. Running lineageos 8.0.
edit2: actually it doesn't work. Givs me a device not supported error
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Possible operator error. Also, this isn't designed for Oreo to begin with.
atrac17 said:
Possible operator error. Also, this isn't designed for Oreo to begin with.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
How is it possible user error if it wasn't designed for Oreo? you never mentioned what os it was meant for. In any case, it did not, in fact, work for Oreo. However I did successfully use it for 7. Thanks for your work.
HatchetJackk said:
How is it possible user error if it wasn't designed for Oreo? you never mentioned what os it was meant for. In any case, it did not, in fact, work for Oreo. However I did successfully use it for 7. Thanks for your work.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
At first, I was saying it's an operator error because it does work. Of course it doesn't work for Oreo it clearly states the date when I pulled the framework in May. The OP was asking to use an updated dialer in stock. I provided him the framework with the ability to do so.... I wouldn't specify why because I was answering the OP.
atrac17 said:
At first, I was saying it's an operator error because it does work. Of course it doesn't work for Oreo it clearly states the date when I pulled the framework in May. The OP was asking to use an updated dialer in stock. I provided him the framework with the ability to do so.... I wouldn't specify why because I was answering the OP.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Understood. Hopefully you can understand my side, as well. Again, thanks for your work.
PumaPerez said:
Hi,
i am perfectly fine with stock ROM and only one thing i would like to have beside. And it is Google phone app with capability to do search nearby places right from the phone app and the capability to see who actually calling behind unknown number.
I see some apks on apkmirror, but latest nonnexus apk is from 2016. So i rather ask here first. Do you guys tried this app and can confirm it has all the features i would like to have? Is it possible to have this app on our phone?
Do you have link to app for our device?
Thank you
https://www.apkmirror.com/uploads/?q=google-phone
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You can check my thread.. I've ported the google dialer to non rooted devices
https://forum.xda-developers.com/mo...-161735957-t3636608/post73025780#post73025780
abhishekiswithyou said:
You can check my thread.. I've ported the google dialer to non rooted devices
https://forum.xda-developers.com/mo...-161735957-t3636608/post73025780#post73025780
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
How do I use this app, if I've a rooted device, pls assist, thanks :good:
talk2indrajit said:
How do I use this app, if I've a rooted device, pls assist, thanks :good:
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
same procedure as non rooted devices, Install as normal apk
I can confirm that it works on Moto G5 Plus (Sanders), stock rom, rooted with Magisk. Installed the dialer framework from the post by @atrac17 above, then phone apk (v.11) from here. (Play Market installation was still showing as unavailable for my device.) Then all I needed to do was to change the default phone app to google phone rather than Moto. Thanks for your help, guys. Couldn't figure it out by myself.
So freaking annoying we have to do this!.. Why on earth do we need Moto's dialer?!

Conused about Xposed on Touchwiz, Nova launcher, Marschmallow

Hello
I'm a little confused about xposed and modules on stock rom for Galaxy S5. May be someone can answer my questions.
I rooted my G900F, Marschmallow 6.0.1 and installed TWRP. Then I installed Xposed Framework V89. On my phone is the stock rom installed. I used Touchwiz UI, but changed to Nova launcher.
Now, I read warnings about bootloops while using Xposed with Samsung devices. I wonder if this affects my device too.
1. Since I use Nova Launcher, is Touchwiz still an possible issue?
2. Is Xposed by itself the 'danger' part or are it the modules? So far I installed one module. Everything works fine.
3. When I open Xposed Installer version 89 there is a warning: There seems to be a known Issue (Samsung Touchwiz Rom) with your Rom. Install Xposed might not work or lead to severe problems.
If my phone is affected, what is the best possible way to avoid potential issue? I red there are unofficial Xposed versions which are modified for samsung stock roms. But I couldn't find any.
Others say, newer version are fine for my phone.
XtraWater said:
1. Since I use Nova Launcher, is Touchwiz still an possible issue?
2. Is Xposed by itself the 'danger' part or are it the modules? So far I installed one module. Everything works fine.
3. When I open Xposed Installer version 89 there is a warning: There seems to be a known Issue (Samsung Touchwiz Rom) with your Rom. Install Xposed might not work or lead to severe problems.
If my phone is affected, what is the best possible way to avoid potential issue? I red there are unofficial Xposed versions which are modified for samsung stock roms. But I couldn't find any.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Nova launcher it's just a launcher, samsung phones ARE touchwiz, not the launcher itself.
Xposed it's the dangerous part, since it's something that edits your phone. Obliviously, if you install incompatible modules that hurts too, just pay attention to install compatible ones.
With a 5sec. search, you can find this thread.
I don't know if newer versions of official xposed are compatible with touchwiz roms, but in this thread there are the unofficial versions that are 100% compatible with yours, just read and download the correct zip.
TENN3R said:
Nova launcher it's just a launcher, samsung phones ARE touchwiz, not the launcher itself.
Xposed it's the dangerous part, since it's something that edits your phone. Obliviously, if you install incompatible modules that hurts too, just pay attention to install compatible ones.
With a 5sec. search, you can find this thread.
I don't know if newer versions of official xposed are compatible with touchwiz roms, but in this thread there are the unofficial versions that are 100% compatible with yours, just read and download the correct zip.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thank you. Very helpful.
On the thread you linked is an download link. The latest version is xposed-v87.1-sdk23-arm-custom-build-by-wanam-20161125.zip
That's exactly the version I installed first. Later I updated it trough the xposed installer to version 89. Should I rather downgrade to the v87.1 version, or is the new installed 89version a custom build by wanam anyway?
I couldn't figure out which version (modified or not) is right now installed.
XtraWater said:
Thank you. Very helpful.
On the thread you linked is an download link. The latest version is xposed-v87.1-sdk23-arm-custom-build-by-wanam-20161125.zip
That's exactly the version I installed first. Later I updated it trough the xposed installer to version 89. Should I rather downgrade to the v87.1 version, or is the new installed 89version a custom build by wanam anyway?
Edit: Since couldn't find a newer version than xposed-v87.1-sdk23-arm-custom-build-by-wanam-20161125.zip, I downgraded back to this version. Now I leave it as it is.
I couldn't figure out which version (modified or not) is right now installed.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
And the last questions. When I got the correct custom Xposed framework, can modules still screw up my phone?
XtraWater said:
And the last questions. When I got the correct custom Xposed framework, can modules still screw up my phone?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm not sure about the update. But the "normal" version should not even let your samsung phone boot up, so if it works it's ok.
Modules are not related to the official or unofficial version, I mean if you install for example gravitybox it explicitly says: "not try on touchwiz roms"
That's what I mean. Usually informations like this are in the description in the xda thread so you should be able to understand which is good for you and which not.
To add to that, in the Xposed installer, Download section, you can do searches.
Search for touchwiz or samsung to get some results that may let you know if certain modules are for, compatible with, or not for your setup.
The module descriptions in the installer are similar to the OPs of the various module threads. Might make it a little easier initially to get an overview. Then you can go to various module threads if you have questions concerning them.
ZTE Axon 7 A2017U, AospExtended v4.6 ROM, microG (NoGapps), Multiboot, Tapatalk 4.9.5

Is there a Magisk module to remove all google apps and services?

I'm looking to get an Android phone but I don't want any google apps or services on it including the play store. Is there a Magisk module that can remove all the google apps and services and play store from a phone? I did a search for "remove google apps" and other such searches but could not find what I'm looking for. I see that the Aurora app store is an alternative play store. Is it safe to use?
Thank you for your advice!
Easiest would be to just flash a custom ROM and don't bother with installing Gapps. VoilĂ , free of Google apps and services.
Didgeridoohan said:
Easiest would be to just flash a custom ROM and don't bother with installing Gapps. VoilĂ , free of Google apps and services.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thank you for the reply. I agree but from my research I could not find custom ROMs available for the Pixel 3 that are officially supported and stable. Please recommend one if there is one that is officially supported and stable. If there is not I would like to know the steps after I root a phone to remove all the google apps and services.
https://f-droid.org/app/org.droidtr.deletegapps
But its very likely to experience bugs and problems (like force closes). The best option is to use a custom Rom
Or you can try the Nanodroid Module (to install microG), probably better than just remove GApps.
AuroraDroid/-store works as it should. I don't know what you mean by 'safe'.
castrum_doloris said:
https://f-droid.org/app/org.droidtr.deletegapps
But its very likely to experience bugs and problems (like force closes). The best option is to use a custom Rom
Or you can try the Nanodroid Module (to install microG), probably better than just remove GApps.
AuroraDroid/-store works as it should. I don't know what you mean by 'safe'.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thank you for the reply. Ok I really would rather use a custom ROM. LineageOS to be precise but there is no official support for the Pixel 3. That's why I'm asking if there is a way, after rooting the phone, to remove all the google apps and services. You mentioned MicroG but does that actually remove all the google apps and services? I looked up MicroG and it looks to be for people who still want to use google apps and services but securely. I don't use anything google apps or services. There are some Microsoft apps I need for work so that's why I asked about Aurora. When I asked if Aurora is safe I meant does Aurora track or do anything unsecure.
Is there a LineageOS custom ROM that does work with the Pixel 3? If not then do I use MicroG to remove all the google stuff?
Sorry to ask so many questions. I've spent hours researching this stuff and there is so much info I read up on that I just need some clarity. Thanks for your patience.
ToughDBlue said:
I'm looking to get an Android phone but I don't want any google apps or services on it including the play store. Is there a Magisk module that can remove all the google apps and services and play store from a phone? I did a search for "remove google apps" and other such searches but could not find what I'm looking for. I see that the Aurora app store is an alternative play store. Is it safe to use?
Thank you for your advice!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
To get rid of issues, uninstall any google apps you want systemlessly using Debloater ( Terminal Emulator ).
ToughDBlue said:
I'm looking to get an Android phone but I don't want any google apps or services on it including the play store. Is there a Magisk module that can remove all the google apps and services and play store from a phone? I did a search for "remove google apps" and other such searches but could not find what I'm looking for. I see that the Aurora app store is an alternative play store. Is it safe to use?
Thank you for your advice!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You are in luck. Get a huawei phone.
Sent from my SM-G985F using Tapatalk
ToughDBlue said:
Thank you for the reply. Ok I really would rather use a custom ROM. LineageOS to be precise but there is no official support for the Pixel 3. That's why I'm asking if there is a way, after rooting the phone, to remove all the google apps and services.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
"Official" and "unofficial" are quite often just terms to clarify, if the builder is part of the dev-team and/or if the Rom/Code is reviewed by one of the dev-team. It is possible, that an unofficial Rom isn't working as good as an official would, but I experienced this quite rarely.
BUT: unofficials usually don't have the possibility to OTA update.
But in the end, "official" and "unofficial" doesn't have to mean much
So my tip: Install and try some Roms, unofficial ones too ^_^
ToughDBlue said:
You mentioned MicroG but does that actually remove all the google apps and services? I looked up MicroG and it looks to be for people who still want to use google apps and services but securely. I don't use anything google apps or services. There are some Microsoft apps I need for work so that's why I asked about Aurora.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
MicroG is an open source and privacy focused Google Services Framework. Its goal is to let apps work, which rely on GApps. I suggested it to grant a bit more stability to your un-googled stock Rom. Because the GApps are most likely deep buried into your (Stock)System, which can lead to severe instability and crashes if you just forcibly rip them out.
At least that's my experience. I never had a usable system with a blank removal of GApps
On a custom Rom its not necessary, if all apps you use work without GApps
ToughDBlue said:
When I asked if Aurora is safe I meant does Aurora track or do anything unsecure.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No, Aurora is safe as far as I know (I'm using it myself)
If you are in doubt (and able to) you can check its source code
ToughDBlue said:
Is there a LineageOS custom ROM that does work with the Pixel 3? If not then do I use MicroG to remove all the google stuff?
Sorry to ask so many questions. I've spent hours researching this stuff and there is so much info I read up on that I just need some clarity. Thanks for your patience.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I can try to check later. An "official" Lineage is quite unlikely, but maybe I find smth else
But yes, if you can't find a fitting Rom, you'll have to try with manually debloating/microG.
You can try to debloat your phone slowly with "Terminal Debloater" like someone already suggested.
One App/Service after another. If smth breaks, you can simply revert it, because this works systemless
No problem, just ask XDA is a forum and I'm here to help
Lineage is available for Pixel 3. It is unofficial, but built by someone on the Lineage team. Check the Pixel 3xl forum. Most custom roms are posted there, but are actually for both devices. The thing is, most custom roms for the device come with GAPPs included (Including Lineage), so not useful for you. This is getting OT though.
castrum_doloris said:
"Official" and "unofficial" are quite often just terms to clarify, if the builder is part of the dev-team and/or if the Rom/Code is reviewed by one of the dev-team. It is possible, that an unofficial Rom isn't working as good as an official would, but I experienced this quite rarely.
BUT: unofficials usually don't have the possibility to OTA update.
But in the end, "official" and "unofficial" doesn't have to mean much
So my tip: Install and try some Roms, unofficial ones too ^_^
MicroG is an open source and privacy focused Google Services Framework. Its goal is to let apps work, which rely on GApps. I suggested it to grant a bit more stability to your un-googled stock Rom. Because the GApps are most likely deep buried into your (Stock)System, which can lead to severe instability and crashes if you just forcibly rip them out.
At least that's my experience. I never had a usable system with a blank removal of GApps
On a custom Rom its not necessary, if all apps you use work without GApps
No, Aurora is safe as far as I know (I'm using it myself)
If you are in doubt (and able to) you can check its source code
I can try to check later. An "official" Lineage is quite unlikely, but maybe I find smth else
But yes, if you can't find a fitting Rom, you'll have to try with manually debloating/microG.
You can try to debloat your phone slowly with "Terminal Debloater" like someone already suggested.
One App/Service after another. If smth breaks, you can simply revert it, because this works systemless
No problem, just ask XDA is a forum and I'm here to help
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thank you for the very detailed reply. Very helpful. I decided to get a Oneplus 7T and not a Pixel 3. I did research and found that most custom ROMs for the Oneplus 7T do not officially support Android 10 as well as MicroG and TWRP. The unofficial custom ROMs note that there are bugs and some instability currently. Being a newbie and needing my Oneplus 7T to be reliable as it's my only phone I rather have an officially supported LineageOS with MicroG custom ROM when it's released. Until then I need help figuring out the best method to remove all gapps and services. I don't use any google apps. I do use Microsoft apps so I need those to not only work but be able to send notifications. I also need to have location services work for a non-google maps app and weather app. I would like to keep Oxygen OS as it has some customizations features I like. Am I asking too much? Lol. However, since microG is not supported I don't think I can do what I'm looking for since MicroG removes all gapps and services and replaces them including location services ability and notifications. Does Magisk have a module that can do what I'm looking for?
You'll likely find better help in the OP7T forums:
https://forum.xda-developers.com/oneplus-7t
There is a debloater module you could use for this purpose, you'll find it on the Manager downloads section. Keep in mind that anything you do with a Magisk module is a systemless modification and the files will still be on your device (just masked by Magisk) and will return if you every disable/uninstall the module or remove Magisk. If you want a more permanent solution you'll need to use other means.
Didgeridoohan said:
You'll likely find better help in the OP7T forums:
https://forum.xda-developers.com/oneplus-7t
There is a debloater module you could use for this purpose, you'll find it on the Manager downloads section. Keep in mind that anything you do with a Magisk module is a systemless modification and the files will still be on your device (just masked by Magisk) and will return if you every disable/uninstall the module or remove Magisk. If you want a more permanent solution you'll need to use other means.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I couldn't find the Manager downloads on the OP7T forum. Can you provide a direct link to the Manager downloads?
The "Manager downloads" is in the Magisk Manager, the app.
What I meant was that it will likely be easier for you to find help with debloating the device in its own forum.
Didgeridoohan said:
The "Manager downloads" is in the Magisk Manager, the app.
What I meant was that it will likely be easier for you to find help with debloating the device in its own forum.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Got it. Thank you for your help!

Categories

Resources