The latest OTA update made my phone bootloop if i re-flash magisk patched init_boot image...
After I asked Stock users, it looks like it's a GrapheneOS june update + Magisk specific issue.
Do someone else also have this issue?
Phone boots normally, then reboot to recovery instead of reaching lock screen.
For now, I re-flashed panther-factory-2023061402 init_boot.
Have you tried Magisk canary version? or maybe GrapheneOS doesn't like june update and newest Magisk and you need to either go back down to stable Magisk or an older version of Magisk?
Actually, after re-reading your OP, a module might be the cause of the bootloop -- I've recently seen similar behavior from other members where device bootloops or crashes during/right-after loading & starting up -- if you were on the stock ROM I would suggest you loading up in Safe Mode to see if it is a module issue; I don't know anything about GrapheneOS so I don't know if it offers anything similar. I wonder if the adb command to remove modules at boot would work....
mhh, right, i don't have a lot of modules aside hosts, fdroid and busybox, but it may be module-related.
Until now, I did everything with TWRP, but now, well, let's say it's a little more difficult =)
... safe mode works with GrapheneOS, good =)
re-enabling modules one by one until i find the culprit.
... and the failing module was... Magisk built-in Busybox 1.0.5 \o/
Albirew said:
mhh, right, i don't have a lot of modules aside hosts, fdroid and busybox, but it may be module-related.
Until now, I did everything with TWRP, but now, well, let's say it's a little more difficult =)
... safe mode works with GrapheneOS, good =)
re-enabling modules one by one until i find the culprit.
... and the failing module was... Magisk built-in Busybox 1.0.5 \o/
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
knew it....
glad I helped get you there!
Related
Description
overwrites system sound files with silent sounds
Changelog
Battery / Camera
Code:
v1.0.0
- initial release
Source
Battery
Code:
https://github.com/f4bio/magisk-silencer-battery
Camera
Code:
https://github.com/f4bio/magisk-silencer-camera
@f4bio hello mate, do you think you could update the modules to the Magisk Module Template v4 and issue it to the Magisk repo? Also, tried installing the battery silencer on magisk 13.3 and it just wouldn't work, as soon as I install this module Magisk Manager crashes and when I reopen it all my modules are gone :/ tried twice and failed twice. not sure if it's something about my setup or an issue with compatibility of the module with the latest magisk.
de.er said:
@f4bio hello mate, do you think you could update the modules to the Magisk Module Template v4 and issue it to the Magisk repo? Also, tried installing the battery silencer on magisk 13.3 and it just wouldn't work, as soon as I install this module Magisk Manager crashes and when I reopen it all my modules are gone :/ tried twice and failed twice. not sure if it's something about my setup or an issue with compatibility of the module with the latest magisk.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Of course. I'll get right on it.
Which phone/rom are causing troubles for you?
I'll just flashed some of them on my h850/flumics/magisk13.3 without problems.
But, I will look into it asap
f4bio said:
Of course. I'll get right on it.
Which phone/rom are causing troubles for you?
I'll just flashed some of them on my h850/flumics/magisk13.3 without problems.
But, I will look into it asap
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm on LG G2 and Resurrection Remix, however, I just clean flashed the latest version followed by magisk and your module installed correctly this time. Still, if you could get it added into the magisk repo that'd be really cool. Thanks
Hi, just report that this DO NOT work on Pixel 3.
I am about to install Magisk 12.0 but never used Magisk before and suddenly unsure if I need something together with Magisk, like SuperSU or similar?
BTJ
Ok, think I found it.. I can use MagiskSU and that one comes with Magisk-12.zip file?
Also, I see there is some talk about needing to install latest dm-verity and forced encryption disabler? I am running stock OOS 4.1.3 and just need root and perhaps install a custom kernel, for now .
Never mind.. Took a chance and installed twrp, Magisk 12 and Franco kernel and everything seems to be working...
xda890 said:
Never mind.. Took a chance and installed twrp, Magisk 12 and Franco kernel and everything seems to be working...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Exact same setup I'm running and it's working great! Time for you to start making some modules next...
I have successfully installed Magisk on my device Root works but when I try to install a magisk module I get an error about not being able to mount magisk.img. When I try to install through recovery the module is flashes without any errors but once you open the app It displays "no modules installed". Before the G5s plus that I have a had the Moto G5 Plus. It had the same problem I just had to install another kernel over stock one and Magisk would work as expected. Is there a kernel for stock room that would support Magisk. Anyone else had this problem or is it just me?
ive no issue installing modules through magisk. Theres a lot of factors here. You didnt mention but id presume you installed magisk through recovery. Also, I presume you installed xposed. Maybe the modules your using require xposed to work. I forgot the exact steps to install xposed through magisk, but its not hard, and Id assume anyways you tried all of that. Have to flask xposed through recovery if I remember, then you can install xposed app apk too through recovery, then open magisk and install the latest xposed there. Im not using a stock rom, however Im fully confident if you properly rooted, and unlocked your phone of course, (I assume you did, just saying) its not a kernel issue. Sorry if I wasnt any help, its all i can think of right now.
When I got the phone I unlocked the bootloader and installed TWRP. When I set up my device I went back to recovery to install Magisk 14.3. It installed correctly and I got root using Magisk but when I try to install any module through the Magisk app I get an error. If I got you right should I try to install Xposed too? I was planning to install Xposed, Magisk version. But when I try that I get an error. I have attached a screenshot of when I try to install Xposed by topjohnwu and Greenify for Magisk. I get the same error.
well, xposed may not be your issue if you cant install any module with magisk manager. The modules, majority of them, if not all of them, i dont know, do not require xposed. Some do, most do not. Now please keep in mind, i could be wrong. I would say this, no harm in installing xposed, its basically a must get anyways for many awesome apps/modules. How you install, first install the xposed manager, youll have to look around for it, its not on the play store. Then downkoad magisk xposed through magisk. Once you download that zip file boot into twrp and install xposed through twrp.
This is a youtube on it: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MCcvsOp83A4 Now thing is, this may not fix any of your problems. But theres a chance it may. Like i said either way you want xposed on rooted phones anyways.
Patched kernel for stock. I have no problem running modules on Magisk. Flash in recovery.
https://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?p=73930507
Sent by way of magic
if youre using stock rom, try this kernel. i just compiled it today from geneticengineers git. last updated hours ago.
Ae3NerdGod said:
if youre using stock rom, try this kernel. i just compiled it today from geneticengineers git. last updated hours ago.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
UPDATE, just found out wifi doesnt work, sorry, been traveling and didnt think to test. everything else seems to work tho.
heres an older version of the kernel not compiled by me until i figure this out
Ae3NerdGod said:
UPDATE, just found out wifi doesnt work, sorry, been traveling and didnt think to test. everything else seems to work tho.
heres an older version of the kernel not compiled by me until i figure this out
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Is there a thread for these kernels or any for G5S Plus?
THERAJ12 said:
Is there a thread for these kernels or any for G5S Plus?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
https://forum.xda-developers.com/moto-g5s-plus/development/kernel-t3707143/post74562730#post74562730
wifi fixed btw
Hi,
I was running stock ROM with stock recovery plus Magisk v16 and MagiskManager v5.9.1 on my Galaxy S8 and Nougat. As far as I remember I did install MagiskManager using adb, pushed, patched and pulled the boot.img, flashed it using Heimdall. Both apk and patched_boot.img are available on my hard disk...
I then updated MagiskManager using the in app update. Afterwards I used the "direct install" to update Magisk. That took me to 20.4 / 8.0.2. I don't remember if it asked to install the runtime.
I installed modules busybox, sqlite3 and movecertificates, but with no effect (e.g. there is no /system/bin/sqlite3, no nc in my path, user certs remain user certs). I also can't find any indication in MagiskManager that modules are installed.
I didn't have time to figure out what's wrong and tried to revert back to my old versions.
That's what I did: Full uninstall from MagiskManager 8.0.2. Reboot without Magisk, adb push MagiskManager-v5.9.1.apk. Flash my old patched_boot with Magisk v16 using Heimdall. But unfortunately that gives me Magisk Manager stuck on the splash sceen. No applet can get root access, e.g. su on adb shell blocks (needs ctrl+c). Ok, uninstalled MM.
I installed the stock boot img in the intention to load MM 8.0.2 before I flash M 20.4. That didn't accept my pattern for the "your device is encrypted" screen. Well... I flashed M 20.4 patched boot.img again. After first try it shows an integrity issue and offers to wipe the phone.
* Anyway to go from here besides wipe?
* What residuals might be blocking when returning to the old versions?
* Why are modules not working on current version?
Thank you
urbancubb said:
* Why are modules not working on current version?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Are they current module zips, or ones that you had laying around from before updating? The modules might be using outdated installation scripts (that's my prime suspect at least).
* What residuals might be blocking when returning to the old versions?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Magisk v16 is soooo old. It's gonna be almost impossible to give any kind of help with that. Better to update to a current Magisk release.
* Anyway to go from here besides wipe?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have no idea, you'd wan't someone who knows Samsung for that. Your device's forum might be a good place to start.
Didgeridoohan said:
Are they current module zips, or ones that you had laying around from before updating? The modules might be using outdated installation scripts (that's my prime suspect at least).
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I installed them from within Magisk Manager from the online repo.
I noticed that this might be the case, but as there was updates this year I think on at least two of them and none worked, I think its a general problem and not caused by the module itself. Any module I could use to test wich works for sure?
Didgeridoohan said:
Magisk v16 is soooo old. It's gonna be almost impossible to give any kind of help with that. Better to update to a current Magisk release.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Which didn't work... We'll see.
Didgeridoohan said:
I have no idea, you'd wan't someone who knows Samsung for that. Your device's forum might be a good place to start.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Good hint, I started a new thread.
Thank you!
For the modules issue, the only way to know for sure what happened is to look at the install logs and the Magisk log for the following reboot.
So if you get things up and running again, and the issue still persists, make sure to provide those.
One thing I didn't think of before: I recently tried the SafatyNet check (which failed), maybe the failed reboot was the first one after checking, I don't remember exactly.
Hey guys!
I recently flashed my Galaxy Note9 (SM-N960F, One UI 2.5) with TWRP and Magisk, all being the latest version. However my phone would just reboot randomly and I could barely find a pattern. I could only infer that the reboot is system level since most of the time I was launching a system-level app like Bixby, Torch, or just simply swipe down the notification panel. If related, 19:30 seems to be the time my phone would definitely reboot recently.
By ''partly goes back to a previous state' I mean some of my apps would be replaced to their factory version. Like I used YouTube Vanced, and after this one reboot it went back to its factory version. And Gboard was exiled of all its permissions once. My Edge Panel was reset after one boot. Some of the adb tweaks were reset.
I'm half sure this is a kernel problem, and the only modifications I did to my kernel were Magisk and Universal DM-Verity. I don't know if it's a DM-Verity problem.
I tried to disable my root permission for apps but it didn't help. Also Googled how to catch system logs but none of these worked.
If you're experiencing the same problem or have an idea of how to solve this issue please feel free to leave a comment!
Maspon said:
Hey guys!
I recently flashed my Galaxy Note9 (SM-N960F, One UI 2.5) with TWRP and Magisk, all being the latest version. However my phone would just reboot randomly and I could barely find a pattern. I could only infer that the reboot is system level since most of the time I was launching a system-level app like Bixby, Torch, or just simply swipe down the notification panel. If related, 19:30 seems to be the time my phone would definitely reboot recently.
By ''partly goes back to a previous state' I mean some of my apps would be replaced to their factory version. Like I used YouTube Vanced, and after this one reboot it went back to its factory version. And Gboard was exiled of all its permissions once. My Edge Panel was reset after one boot. Some of the adb tweaks were reset.
I'm half sure this is a kernel problem, and the only modifications I did to my kernel were Magisk and Universal DM-Verity. I don't know if it's a DM-Verity problem or I just disabled too many system apps (Galaxy Themes, Bixby Service, Galaxy Friends and stuff).
I tried to disable my root permission for apps but it didn't help. Also Googled how to catch system logs but none of these worked.
Whether you're experiencing the same problem or have an idea of how to solve this issue please feel free to leave a comment!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Happened to me as well few months ago.
I suspect it is related to safetynetfix or hideprop. I used safetynetfix for samsung, and update latest hideprop, now i never experienced the random reboot.
xfakexbloodx said:
Happened to me as well few months ago.
I suspect it is related to safetynetfix or hideprop. I used safetynetfix for samsung, and update latest hideprop, now i never experienced the random reboot.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks for the reply! I just flashed Universal SafetyNet Fix. Now my phone is stuck in bootloop. It would just reboot infinitely. May I possibly get the SafetyNet Fix you're using?
Maspon said:
Thanks for the reply! I just flashed Universal SafetyNet Fix. Now my phone is stuck in bootloop. It would just reboot infinitely. May I possibly get the SafetyNet Fix you're using?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Based on this post
MAGISK MODULE ❯ Universal SafetyNet Fix 2.4.0
Universal SafetyNet Fix Magisk module Magisk module to work around Google's SafetyNet attestation. This module works around hardware attestation and recent updates to SafetyNet CTS profile checks. You must already be able to pass basic CTS...
forum.xda-developers.com
Try to read each page, some people say it works, some people say it doesn't. I've tried and updating my magiskhide prop and it works.
xfakexbloodx said:
Based on this post
MAGISK MODULE ❯ Universal SafetyNet Fix 2.4.0
Universal SafetyNet Fix Magisk module Magisk module to work around Google's SafetyNet attestation. This module works around hardware attestation and recent updates to SafetyNet CTS profile checks. You must already be able to pass basic CTS...
forum.xda-developers.com
Try to read each page, some people say it works, some people say it doesn't. I've tried and updating my magiskhide prop and it works.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks a lot! My phone now boots normaly and it's a Success on SafetyNet. Hope no more random reboots afterwards.
I'm particularly curious what variant of DM-Verity did you use? I googled for DM-Verity for Samsung this morning and did get a Samsung-only patch. I'm not sure if DM-Verity patch could contribute to these reboots.
Maspon said:
Thanks a lot! My phone now boots normaly and it's a Success on SafetyNet. Hope no more random reboots afterwards.
I'm particularly curious what variant of DM-Verity did you use? I googled for DM-Verity for Samsung this morning and did get a Samsung-only patch. I'm not sure if DM-Verity patch could contribute to these reboots.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Sorry no idea about that. I'm using alexis rom though..
xfakexbloodx said:
Sorry no idea about that. I'm using alexis rom though..
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Sadly my phone still rebooted this morning. I caught the last kernel message and I hope it will help