Question Will rooting my pixel 5a allow me to disable camera shutter sound? - Google Pixel 5a

You see, I got a pixel 5a that is imported from Japan and in Japan all phones Manufacturers must have shutter sound when taking pictures and you can't disable it.
If I will root my phone I will be able to disable it, right?

No. Only with root - no. It depends on device ID (US or JP). For p5 there is patch for TWRP that spoofs ID, but there is no TWRP for 5a.
May be with some magisk module but i can't find any.
Or you can use modded Gcam.

Thank you.
I will try download modded Gcam. from here
Google Camera Port Hub: Get the best GCam APK for Samsung, Motorola, OnePlus, and other phones
Looking for the best version of the Google Camera app for your phone? We've rounded up a ton of versions for different models and brands.
www.xda-developers.com
I see there is no "5a" so I will download the one for pixel 5?
edit: thank you very much, the modded Gcam. worked!!

Hi can you share the steps to do this? Also wanting to remove my shutter sound. From your reply, it looks like you need to root it?

kaeel said:
Hi can you share the steps to do this? Also wanting to remove my shutter sound. From your reply, it looks like you need to root it?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No need to root, just download APK of the google camera and use it instead of the one that come with the phone.
That's what I did eventually.
Use modded Gcam like forty-second said

it is impossible to convert 5a sun of the Japanese version into the American version, the difference is in the bands, only use the gcam mod

does the gcam mod has all the features as the built-in camera?

Faced the same issue. Like other people said, removing it from the stock Gcam probably isn't an option. Just use a compatible Gcam mod, I recommend MWP GCam for latest supported version.
As a bonus, you can use Tasker to intercept the double power button gesture to launch the modded GCam instead of stock.

PixelatedFox said:
edit: thank you very much, the modded Gcam. worked!!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
How is it working months later? I am considering buying a Japanese P5A. Your feedback will help me a lot with making a buying decision

JetVoz said:
How is it working months later? I am considering buying a Japanese P5A. Your feedback will help me a lot with making a buying decision
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Excellent, no problems at all.

PixelatedFox said:
Excellent, no problems at all.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Great to hear!! Do you use the cam app from the comment below?
Velcorn said:
I recommend MWP GCam for latest supported version.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Also, would you mind elaborating a bit on your experience with it? I'm especially interested in hearing about two things that were discussed in this thread:
rokphish said:
does the gcam mod has all the features as the built-in camera?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Velcorn said:
use Tasker to intercept the double power button gesture to launch the modded GCam instead of stock.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
----
Thank you!

JetVoz said:
Great to hear!! Do you use the cam app from the comment below?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No, I use What I said here.... the modded Gcam
PixelatedFox said:
Thank you.
I will try download modded Gcam. from here
Google Camera Port Hub: Get the best GCam APK for Samsung, Motorola, OnePlus, and other phones
Looking for the best version of the Google Camera app for your phone? We've rounded up a ton of versions for different models and brands.
www.xda-developers.com
I see there is no "5a" so I will download the one for pixel 5?
edit: thank you very much, the modded Gcam. worked!!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse

Several Android versions ago I used to use Root Explorer and delete the system sound for camera shutter, which worked at the time. Maybe worth exploring?

I remembered there was a thread in the Pixel 5 community. It provides a way to permanently alter the device model code to disable these Japan-only features. Maybe it works on Pixel 5a?
It may not be simple, but can permanently eliminate similar problems.

PF2350 said:
I remembered there was a thread in the Pixel 5 community. It provides a way to permanently alter the device model code to disable these Japan-only features. Maybe it works on Pixel 5a?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
FYI.
Turn off shutter sound from pixel bought in japan
Due to pixel was not sold I was buying pixel 5 from japan. I thought if I flash a US ROM the shutter sound (japan shutter sound law) will go away but it seems like it is still going strong even after I used Cambodia sim. It was used outside japan...
forum.xda-developers.com

Hello all,
I also have a Japan model of the 5a, and a while ago I put together a Magisk module to disable the shutter sound.
Let me know if you run into issues.
Release v1.1.0 · averne/barbet-screenshot-sound
Magisk module to mute the camera sound on the Pixel 5a - Release v1.1.0 · averne/barbet-screenshot-sound
github.com

Hi @averne_
could you please make the sound camera_click not empty, but with silence and not zero like it is now as it crashes some devices? Thank you! I can't attach the file here, but you can find silent 1sec ogg files online.
I can't make it work - Magisk doesn't allow me to unzip the file no idea why.

maliciousd12 said:
Hi @averne_
could you please make the sound camera_click not empty, but with silence and not zero like it is now as it crashes some devices? Thank you! I can't attach the file here, but you can find silent 1sec ogg files online.
I can't make it work - Magisk doesn't allow me to unzip the file no idea why.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Let me know if that works better
Release v1.2.0 · averne/barbet-screenshot-sound
Magisk module to mute the camera sound on the Pixel 5a - Release v1.2.0 · averne/barbet-screenshot-sound
github.com

JetVoz said:
How is it working months later? I am considering buying a Japanese P5A. Your feedback will help me a lot with making a buying decision
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It works like a charm here in Italy

Related

Google camera bypass moto processing?

I know the zealous sharpening issue with the stock moto is a post processing problem and has been mention if not rooted no actual fix yet.. Also others have stated open camera didn't take any better pictures... However I'm wondering if certain apps simply rely on the OS post processing and don't have their own built in. As I used Google camera today to take 2 exact pictures. I sat holding my hand in exactly the same position without moving.. Then launched the stock camera and the comparison is a visibly less noisy and softer photo. I will upload the comparison
Attatched photos taken with both cameras. No hdr no settings adjusted same place touched to focus.
i named each file accordingly. but incase you cant see file names.
goes moto google then for st shot google moto
On custom roms, the Google camera is great, but still has a few issues. Sometimes, it only allowed me to take a few photos at one, and then stopped letting me take any. I had to exit out and go back in to fix it. That said, I saw it on the lineage camera and open camera to...
Either way, the big problem in find is other apps using the camera, which seems to either not work or show a very dark image. This affected mostly QR apps in my experience, (2 factor apps, WhatsApp, etc.)
What version of Google Camera did you use?
atrac17 said:
What version of Google Camera did you use?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The latest 2.5.052
alevity said:
The latest 2.5.052
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks, I tried 4.1.006 with some buildprop tweaks and 2.7.008; just was curious if you were using the target sdk version for stock or not.
atrac17 said:
Thanks, I tried 4.1.006 with some buildprop tweaks and 2.7.008; just was curious if you were using the target sdk version for stock or not.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
How did you guys installed Google Camera, since it's not compatible with the G5 plus? Is there an apk? Thanks
LiteSoul said:
How did you guys installed Google Camera, since it's not compatible with the G5 plus? Is there an apk? Thanks
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
https://labs.xda-developers.com/store/app/com.google.android.GoogleCameraMOD
alevity said:
https://labs.xda-developers.com/store/app/com.google.android.GoogleCameraMOD
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Sorry maybe this one isn't compatible. You'll need a apk off a mirror site but I don't know which to trust so will leave that decision to you
Nah, that's for a different processor I think. I can't find it
LiteSoul said:
How did you guys installed Google Camera, since it's not compatible with the G5 plus? Is there an apk? Thanks
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I downloaded the versions listed previously from apkmirror and enabled camera2 in build.prop. There is a Magisk Module for enabling camera2 now as well.
I had no issues with 2.7.008, but 4.1.006 would occasionally fc when switching from camera to video.
persist.camera.HAL3.enabled=1 is the build.prop I used.
Someone please kindly share me the APK of Google Camera for non-rooted Moto G5 Plus. I thought I could also use it in my phone!
atrac17 said:
There is a Magisk Module for enabling camera2 now as well.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Could you please share where we can find this magisk module?
Some1CP said:
Could you please share where we can find this magisk module?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If you search, XDA has everything easily accessible.
atrac17 said:
If you search, XDA has everything easily accessible.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yeah, I already tried looking for it but couldn't find anything on the G5 Plus forum.
For anyone who is interested:
https://www.xda-developers.com/camera2api-magisk-module-enables/
I havent rooted my phone yet. Has anyone here tried this?
https://www.xda-developers.com/google-camera-hdr-customization-raw-support/
The 625 does have the DSP, so has anyone tried it?
reganEZ said:
I havent rooted my phone yet. Has anyone here tried this?
https://www.xda-developers.com/google-camera-hdr-customization-raw-support/
The 625 does have the DSP, so has anyone tried it?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Only works on 64 bit devices... Unfortunately we have 64 capable device, but our OS is 32 bits
abeloman said:
Only works on 64 bit devices... Unfortunately we have 64 capable device, but our OS is 32 bits
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Damn! I knew we had a 32 bit ROM bit I don't know it brought such limitations with it. Maybe we see 64 bit with andrpid O.
Thanks for the reply.
After installing the Gcam , can you still use the moto app?
nona89 said:
After installing the Gcam , can you still use the moto app?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes u can

Google Camera with HDR+ Ported to Snapdragon 820/821 and 835 Devices

This in no way shape or fashion is my work. I found this and it's working great on my S8+and is also working on my Note 8.
https://www.xda-developers.com/goog...gn=Feed:+xda-developers/ShsH+(xda-developers)
Note 8
Crashes on startup on my unrooted Note 8. Any idea why?
HiGreen said:
Crashes on startup on my unrooted Note 8. Any idea why?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Is it a snapdragon? Working on my T-Mobile snapdragon variant.
ggrant3876 said:
Is it a snapdragon? Working on my T-Mobile snapdragon variant.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This is embarrasing, but no. It is not. Thank you for your time!
HiGreen said:
This is embarrasing, but no. It is not. Thank you for your time!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I did the same thing. Don't feel bad.
It didn't work on my phone at first. I had to reboot the phone then it worked fine.
ggrant3876 said:
This in no way shape or fashion is my work. I found this and it's working great on my S8+and is also working on my Note 8.
https://www.xda-developers.com/goog...gn=Feed:+xda-developers/ShsH+(xda-developers)
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This works so much better than the stock HDR feature - it's actually one of the main reasons why I insisted on a Snapdragon model.
Does anyone know the video recording limit on this camera app ?
https://www.xda-developers.com/google-camera-hdr-customization-raw-support/amp/
Skickat från min SM-N950F via Tapatalk
ggrant3876 said:
Is it a snapdragon? Working on my T-Mobile snapdragon variant.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have the samsung unlocked version running on sprint, but I what do I have?
Also does it work side by side with the existing cam? I will be able to chose whichever cam I want to use?
psixichka said:
I have the samsung unlocked version running on sprint, but I what do I have?
Also does it work side by side with the existing cam? I will be able to chose whichever cam I want to use?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
There should be a download link on the post, it's right above the interview with the developer. Yes, I have them both installed on my home screen and they both work fine. Just install it like a regular apk.
Seems Note 8‘s camera works as well as google camera?
Is there somewhere that explains the differences in the various algorithms? I searched around but found only bits and pieces.
Also, it would be nice if someone could post which settings actually work for the Note 8. I tried a few and some wouldn't save and others
(I'm not a big camera buff and really don't use my phone's camera that much, otherwise I would.)
I'm seeing people state that the Google Camera is a bit better than the Stock Samsung one, but my experience is the opposite. Google Camera is giving me bad low light performance. I even used setting from the forums and was still subpar. What settings are you guys using?
I couldn't get this to work on my AT&T Note8 un-rooted.
dccoh said:
I'm seeing people state that the Google Camera is a bit better than the Stock Samsung one, but my experience is the opposite. Google Camera is giving me bad low light performance. I even used setting from the forums and was still subpar. What settings are you guys using?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Which settings from the forums? You have a link we can try? Thanks.
Unlocked non-rooted on Verizon and installs fine. Samsung Camera is far superior including with HDR so I'll un-install now...
Any news on making this work on Note 8 Exynos variant?
It works only on snapdrago phones
deadlyheart4u said:
It works only on snapdrago phones
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Not correct. Works on Exynos too but if you try to make any changes to settings it'll crash. Only way to revive is by clearing storage from settings!
However I didn't find it significantly better than stock camera and night time/poor lit/dark conditions photos are definitely better with stock camera.

Question Asus Stock Camera App, Please !

Hi XDA,
Can anyone please pull the stock Asus Zenfone8 app(as an .apk) so we can use it on custom ROMs ?
I compared the stock Asus camera app with all availabe apps before installing the LineageOS and the difference is huge, specially comparing it to the OpenCamera.
The stock app is way better.
I wish I can have it on my LineageOS now
Appreciate your help so much!
I have attached the extracted APK here, I hope it works!:
Adaoh said:
I have attached the extracted APK here, I hope it works!:
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks, I'll give it a try,
Just 1 question please, how were you able to got it?
Was it taken directly from the Zenfone8 ?
adam.718 said:
Thanks, I'll give it a try,
Just 1 question please, how were you able to got it?
Was it taken directly from the Zenfone8 ?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes, I got it directly from my phone. I extracted it with an adb command. It was my first time doing that so I don't know if I did it properly
Adaoh said:
Yes, I got it directly from my phone. I extracted it with an adb command. It was my first time doing that so I don't know if I did it properly
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Does not work in Lineage. I’ll see if I can get it from the original img.
Mecallie said:
Does not work in Lineage. I’ll see if I can get it from the original img.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Well, I was hoping it was some kind of img file. But it's a zip with a .bin file. Not a clue as to what I can do with that. Would be great to get the stock camera. The Lineage camera really sucks and I cannot get any of the gcam versions to work either...
If that helps, I was able to get OK results on the stock ROM from the GrapheneOS Camera app. You can get it from their github repository. Note that it is very basic and lacks any night mode or any kind of special features. Also I just noticed that it does not offer the option of switching lenses. Maybe it is possible but I didn't search on that subject. Here are some comparison images
Mecallie said:
Well, I was hoping it was some kind of img file. But it's a zip with a .bin file. Not a clue as to what I can do with that. Would be great to get the stock camera. The Lineage camera really sucks and I cannot get any of the gcam versions to work either...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hi, I tested it as well and had no sucess. As a developer I also tried to unpack the apk and take a look, imeediatly noticed that it has some google dependencies which in my case a LineageOS with no google will not work, as well I saw some properties and configurations files so maybe these has some data related to the phone of the good guy who ported it out.
The stock camera app is way better than the most famous free camera apps out there, specially in night photography, the OpenCamera for example leaves you night photos so so noisy and it sets the screen brightness on max with no way to change that (not that I know).
Lets please keep this thread running to find out the best camera for this phone with AOSP and no google dependneces.
Tested the Witchaya Port of GCam yesterday. No luck with Version 8 (just crashes), but Version 7 first seemed to run. Yet it freezes the captured image constantly after 3 seconds. Tapping onto a different camera mode wakes the image again for 3 seconds - just to freeze again afterwards. Tried all of the supplied xml config files - no success. I'm running on latest LineageOS nightly without the GApps...
I believe if a good developer can take a look at the stock Asus app and figure out why it doesn't work.
Maybe it's just a deal of adjusting some configuration file.
On another thread, what's the best free Camera app you're using ?
I'm using the OpenCamera since it has lots of options, but its photo quality is not the best and night shoots are so noisy.
Asus camera is dependant of asus framework . Most likely nogo to get it to run on non as roms.
Its not as simple as config files, it much deeper integrated in asus framework
NisseGurra said:
Asus camera is dependant of asus framework . Most likely nogo to get it to run on non as roms.
Its not as simple as config files, it much deeper integrated in asus framework
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Appreciate your clarification.
adam.718 said:
Appreciate your clarification.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Any news regarding cam so far? Been fiddling around with opencamera and the lineageOS cam, but the results are rather disappointing.
Would appreciate any further development in this case.
Thanks, happy new year!
Winnie_LD said:
Any news regarding cam so far? Been fiddling around with opencamera and the lineageOS cam, but the results are rather disappointing.
Would appreciate any further development in this case.
Thanks, happy new year!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Same exact situation here
Just gave the GrapheneOS camera app a try, it looks more promising, hope they will keep on upgrading it.
I raised an issue for supporting the ultra-wide lens as well, hope they will work on it.
It's good to keep an eye on this app, thanks to @Adaoh for mentioning it.
Happy new year!
adam.718 said:
Same exact situation here
Just gave the GrapheneOS camera app a try, it looks more promising, hope they will keep on upgrading it.
I raised an issue for supporting the ultra-wide lens as well, hope they will work on it.
It's good to keep an eye on this app, thanks to @Adaoh for mentioning it.
Happy new year!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Nice hint, thank you! Just installed it, seems to work fine except for the ultra-wide lens, as you mentioned already.
I have tried OmniRom, and it has an Asus camera port that works I will be asking the maintainer if he is fine with me sharing the APK.
Adaoh said:
I have tried OmniRom, and it has an Asus camera port that works I will be asking the maintainer if he is fine with me sharing the APK.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yeah, let's give it a try. Nothin to loose...
Here is the OmniRom APK
Adaoh said:
Here is the OmniRom APK
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thank you @Adaoh ! Unfortunately it does not work for me. After granting access the app displays "Camera not ready. Try again later" (translated from german) and exits. Obviously depending on some other components not available in LineageOS...
Winnie_LD said:
Thank you @Adaoh ! Unfortunately it does not work for me. After granting access the app displays "Camera not ready. Try again later" (translated from german) and exits. Obviously depending on some other components not available in LineageOS...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yeah they warned me about that on the OmniRom telegram group, a friend tested on his Pixel 4a and it worked, so I assumed it would have worked on ZF8

Is there any working GCAM for Note 9 Exynos Variant?

I can't seem to fine any working GCAM for Note 9 Exynos. If anybody has one kindly letme know, I can't stand the stock camera!!
The Zgcam is the best i found.
It's working really nice.
Jonisloth said:
The Zgcam is the best i found.
It's working really nice.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Can you please send me the link to download it?
https://1-dontsharethislink.celsoazevedo.com/file/filesc/ZGCAM_7.4_V1.03387.apk
Here you are
Jonisloth said:
https://1-dontsharethislink.celsoazevedo.com/file/filesc/ZGCAM_7.4_V1.03387.apk
Here you are
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks, I used this GCAM it takes good pictures but it's very slow and glitchy. Stutters a lot, have you noticed any of these issues?
No I haven't. Have you enabled yor camera2api to full support?
Jonisloth said:
No I haven't. Have you enabled yor camera2api to full support?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What's that? Can you please guide me?
Of course!
Camera2api is an android feature that allows having some camera features like the gcam support. Its not fully enabled on default but there is an easy way to do it.
First of all your phone has to be rooted with magisk (magisk is not necessarily needed but it's way easier with it).
Then you have to download an app called camera2api enabler which you can find in the Playstore.
Accept the Super user request and just let the app do it's job.
Jonisloth said:
Of course!
Camera2api is an android feature that allows having some camera features like the gcam support. Its not fully enabled on default but there is an easy way to do it.
First of all your phone has to be rooted with magisk (magisk is not necessarily needed but it's way easier with it).
Then you have to download an app called camera2api enabler which you can find in the Playstore.
Accept the Super user request and just let the app do it's job.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Ohh, I see. I used to do rooting a long time ago, didn't even realized its still a thing in 2022. I gotcha your point it will require some fiddling to do. Gcam used to work perfectly in my Galaxy S8 however jn this Note 9 it's is giving me nightmares. Lol!! and thanks man you have helped alot, really appreciate it!!
No problem I help where ever i can.

Question Magic eraser

Hello,
Anybody had magic eraser work on the OnePlus 10 pro?
EMJI79 said:
Hello,
Anybody had magic eraser work on the OnePlus 10 pro?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Are you talking about an app to just wipe the entire phone? If so, Android all in one tool works for that via adb and fastboot. I had to use it after changing my password on bootup and ****ing up both of the new ones the same way, lost all of my years of Google data
If you mean the feature on the pixel 6 where you can pick and remove assets in photos, then no the 10 pro doesn't have it.
But you do have lightroom on android though.
EMJI79 said:
Hello,
Anybody had magic eraser work on the OnePlus 10 pro?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Open stock OnePlus photos app and tap editor they have one built in
I am talking about the Pixel 6 feature. I have read articles that it was ported to other devices a time ago, other Pixels and rooted devices and wondered if it was available for the OnePlus 10 pro through a mod now.
The object eraser in Lightroom is a paid feature as far as I know.
EMJI79 said:
I am talking about the Pixel 6 feature. I have read articles that it was ported to other devices a time ago, other Pixels and rooted devices and wondered if it was available for the OnePlus 10 pro through a mod now.
The object eraser in Lightroom is a paid feature as far as I know.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No mod, it's in stock OnePlus photos app under edit option of picture
toolhas4degrees said:
No mod, it's in stock OnePlus photos app under edit option of picture
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I've used it it's not even close to the pixel one IMHO, but still a useful feature if you can get the background merge done right
dladz said:
I've used it it's not even close to the pixel one IMHO, but still a useful feature if you can get the background merge done
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Exactly
toolhas4degrees said:
No mod, it's in stock OnePlus photos app under edit option of picture
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Ok thanks!
dladz said:
I've used it it's not even close to the pixel one IMHO, but still a useful feature if you can get the background merge done right
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You can use Xposed Google photos mod to activate the one in Google photos also if you are rooted and have lsposed
toolhas4degrees said:
You can use Xposed Google photos mod to activate the one in Google photos also if you are rooted and have lsposed
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Nah not for me Xposed hits my battery regardless what mods I use.
EMJI79 said:
Hello,
Anybody had magic eraser work on the OnePlus 10 pro?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It gives a module for that at Telegram. But never tested it.
Modules Repository | #TeamFiles
All the files you need for customizing your Android device! #TeamFiles chat: @fileschat #TeamFiles announcements: @teamfilesannouncements More from #TeamFiles: @filesfederation Off-topic Group: @TeamFilesOT
t.me

Categories

Resources