Related
Yup - not tempered glass, but PET film. It seems that everyone is interested in glass, and in turn, endless amounts of discussion on issues with glass protectors for the N5. I've used PET film a couple of times in the past few weeks of N5 ownership, in between installations of glass protectors. Each time, the PET film was a joy to go back to, for me. I was wondering which brands of film members have tried and what their results were.
For those who are wondering why the hell would anyone even consider using old-school film, here are the Pros/Cons of film protectors as I see them:
Pros:
- Little/no halo: If we were all installing only film protectors on the N5, we would have, by now, settled on a bunch of brands that get really good results for just about everyone. I've seen this evolution happen with a number of new phones. There's no such consensus on glass protectors for the N5.
- Easier install: if you have at least average skills, you are going to get a good, easy and quick install. Don't need to dedicate time to rubbing out edges that are standing up off the screen, and no need to break out the hair dryer.
- Less visible: really hard to tell that there is a protector on the N5.
- Cost: Film is less expensive, but glass has really come down in price as well.
Cons:
- Less protection: Hey, glass is stronger and harder than film, I get that.
- Not as smooth as glass: although film can be very good, glass is just smoother.
In my experience, it's not until I put a film protector on that I say "Damn, that looks great!" Often I can see a glass protector on a phone at a distance. If it's not the halo it's the edges top and bottom just looking like a protector stuck on the display.
So, I am not starting a case for glass vs film, I just would like to know what film you folks have used on the N5. I use Spigen film and the first install had the tiniest amount of halo above the earpiece (I don't think there should be protector in that area), but everything else was spot-on perfect. The second film is spot-on perfect all around. I have another brand in-bound as we speak.
I bought this 3 and will be able to provide some feedback in ~2 weeks ))
http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B014R5DMIU?psc=1&redirect=true&ref_=oh_aui_detailpage_o01_s00
http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B010DB2ROC?psc=1&redirect=true&ref_=oh_aui_detailpage_o02_s00
http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B010MWD59I?psc=1&redirect=true&ref_=oh_aui_detailpage_o02_s00
Cool.
I recall someone here saying that they use that brand with good results.
Over at Android Central, a number of N5 owners are now discovering the advantages of PET film.
Hey, it all depends on what you want.
I am still rocking the Spigen film. I'd say it looks perfect, but you really have to look closely to see any evidence of a protector.
billykxda said:
Over at Android Central, a number of N5 owners are now discovering the advantages of PET film.
Hey, it all depends on what you want.
I am still rocking the Spigen film. I'd say it looks perfect, but you really have to look closely to see any evidence of a protector.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No halo on that one?
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-N920A
I have the ones from iCarez and they don't cover past the light sensors on top which leaves an exposed area, same goes to the bottom where the home key is, but not as much.
I would also like feedback on the Pleson ones especially if they play well with a TPU Hybrid case.
Spigen and it's pretty awesome. Can't even tell it's on both by looks and feel.
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-N920A using Tapatalk
ambervals6 said:
No halo on that one?
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-N920A
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No halo on my second install. PET film is far more forgivable b/c it can easily follow the curve on the display edges. That's a major advantage for those of us who want their N5 to look great - as it was designed to do. For me, glass protectors always appear to be less-than-great looking layers of glass stuck on the front of an elegantly-designed N5. So, for now, I am happily rocking a film protector.
I purchased another brand of film protectors, but I am going to hold-off on trying them out. The Spigen is just too perfect to pull-off.
I use a Ringke Slim case that does not interfere with the film at all. I had a more robust Spigen Hybrid case on with the first Spigen film I had installed, and the case would flex inwards occasionally when pressing the power button, lifting it up momentarily, but then it would just lay back down. The Ringke case is particularly good for use with full-size protectors.
billykxda said:
Yup - not tempered glass, but PET film. It seems that everyone is interested in glass, and in turn, endless amounts of discussion on issues with glass protectors for the N5. I've used PET film a couple of times in the past few weeks of N5 ownership, in between installations of glass protectors. Each time, the PET film was a joy to go back to, for me. I was wondering which brands of film members have tried and what their results were.
For those who are wondering why the hell would anyone even consider using old-school film, here are the Pros/Cons of film protectors as I see them:
Pros:
- Little/no halo: If we were all installing only film protectors on the N5, we would have, by now, settled on a bunch of brands that get really good results for just about everyone. I've seen this evolution happen with a number of new phones. There's no such consensus on glass protectors for the N5.
- Easier install: if you have at least average skills, you are going to get a good, easy and quick install. Don't need to dedicate time to rubbing out edges that are standing up off the screen, and no need to break out the hair dryer.
- Less visible: really hard to tell that there is a protector on the N5.
- Cost: Film is less expensive, but glass has really come down in price as well.
Cons:
- Less protection: Hey, glass is stronger and harder than film, I get that.
- Not as smooth as glass: although film can be very good, glass is just smoother.
In my experience, it's not until I put a film protector on that I say "Damn, that looks great!" Often I can see a glass protector on a phone at a distance. If it's not the halo it's the edges top and bottom just looking like a protector stuck on the display.
So, I am not starting a case for glass vs film, I just would like to know what film you folks have used on the N5. I use Spigen film and the first install had the tiniest amount of halo above the earpiece (I don't think there should be protector in that area), but everything else was spot-on perfect. The second film is spot-on perfect all around. I have another brand in-bound as we speak.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Can you please post some photos of your Note with the spigen film? Right now I'm using the Nillkin glass and I'm terribly disappointed! I may consider got back to pet films after many years with glass protector!
Thanks in advance!
Tapatalked with my Note 5
dsmpampis said:
Can you please post some photos of your Note with the spigen film? Right now I'm using the Nillkin glass and I'm terribly disappointed! I may consider got back to pet films after many years with glass protector!
Thanks in advance!
Tapatalked with my Note 5
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I don't have a second phone/camera around to do so. Just tried using my webcam - you don't want to see what that looked like.
Just imagine not seeing a protector. And there you have it.
-bk
billykxda said:
No halo on my second install. PET film is far more forgivable b/c it can easily follow the curve on the display edges. That's a major advantage for those of us who want their N5 to look great - as it was designed to do. For me, glass protectors always appear to be less-than-great looking layers of glass stuck on the front of an elegantly-designed N5. So, for now, I am happily rocking a film protector.
I purchased another brand of film protectors, but I am going to hold-off on trying them out. The Spigen is just too perfect to pull-off.
I use a Ringke Slim case that does not interfere with the film at all. I had a more robust Spigen Hybrid case on with the first Spigen film I had installed, and the case would flex inwards occasionally when pressing the power button, lifting it up momentarily, but then it would just lay back down. The Ringke case is particularly good for use with full-size protectors.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Have you noticed the fingerprint scanner being any slower to unlock the device since installing the Spigen screen protector? I just installed mine last night and maybe I'm crazy.. But it just seems a lite bit slower than when I had no screen protector. Maybe I'm crazy! Lol.
skadude66 said:
Have you noticed the fingerprint scanner being any slower to unlock the device since installing the Spigen screen protector? I just installed mine last night and maybe I'm crazy.. But it just seems a lite bit slower than when I had no screen protector. Maybe I'm crazy! Lol.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Nope - haven't noticed that at all. Since the protector doesn't go near where the fingerprint detection is going on, I can't imagine how it could interfere.
There's lots of voodoo that's happening with the fingerprint reader that sometimes makes it perfectly accurate, other times less so. Plus, there are the variables involved when you ask a user to configure/set-up complex hardware. I'd look elsewhere.
billykxda said:
Nope - haven't noticed that at all. Since the protector doesn't go near where the fingerprint detection is going on, I can't imagine how it could interfere.
There's lots of voodoo that's happening with the fingerprint reader that sometimes makes it perfectly accurate, other times less so. Plus, there are the variables involved when you ask a user to configure/set-up complex hardware. I'd look elsewhere.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I might have installed mine just a little bit crooked... It EVER so slightly touches the silver ring of the home button, but maybe I'm just crazy and it's not actually affecting anything haha.
No b.s spigen, no b.s expensive brand name. 5pack for $1 best screen protector I have got so far. Bestoffer4yu ebay seller from china.
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-N920A
I got the iCarez and it was perfect on my note4 but on the note5 it has about 1mm of halo on both sides. Not as visible as a tempered glass halo but at right angle you can see it. Its sized to exactly the LCD part so can't be cut any smaller.
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-N920A using Tapatalk
billykxda said:
No halo on my second install. PET film is far more forgivable b/c it can easily follow the curve on the display edges. That's a major advantage for those of us who want their N5 to look great - as it was designed to do. For me, glass protectors always appear to be less-than-great looking layers of glass stuck on the front of an elegantly-designed N5. So, for now, I am happily rocking a film protector.
I purchased another brand of film protectors, but I am going to hold-off on trying them out. The Spigen is just too perfect to pull-off.
I use a Ringke Slim case that does not interfere with the film at all. I had a more robust Spigen Hybrid case on with the first Spigen film I had installed, and the case would flex inwards occasionally when pressing the power button, lifting it up momentarily, but then it would just lay back down. The Ringke case is particularly good for use with full-size protectors.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Did you do anything special when you put it on the second time ? Just installed the Spigen Crystal for the first time on my N5 and there's a halo at the top, continuing a little bit down the sides
Spigen Crystal
{
"lightbox_close": "Close",
"lightbox_next": "Next",
"lightbox_previous": "Previous",
"lightbox_error": "The requested content cannot be loaded. Please try again later.",
"lightbox_start_slideshow": "Start slideshow",
"lightbox_stop_slideshow": "Stop slideshow",
"lightbox_full_screen": "Full screen",
"lightbox_thumbnails": "Thumbnails",
"lightbox_download": "Download",
"lightbox_share": "Share",
"lightbox_zoom": "Zoom",
"lightbox_new_window": "New window",
"lightbox_toggle_sidebar": "Toggle sidebar"
}
Tapatalked with my Note 5
http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B011PYL8C8?psc=1&redirect=true&ref_=oh_aui_detailpage_o01_s01
$6 for six screen protectors - done deal.
I got these first and didn't use them. I was provided a few glass protectors to test. Halo after Halo on the glass, finally I broke these out and opened them. Easy install, no real complaints. I didn't miss the feel of these, but it works with the pen well. Currently have mine, my wife and my moms phone protected with these - and three to spare :highfive:
dsmpampis said:
Spigen Crystal
View attachment 3508573View attachment 3508574View attachment 3508579View attachment 3508580View attachment 3508581
Tapatalked with my Note 5
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That looks amazing. My first install did not come out that well unfortunately any tips ?
vincel892 said:
That looks amazing. My first install did not come out that well unfortunately any tips ?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Have you tried the hinge method? Always works for me.
I like the appearance of PET screen protectors, but compared to glass, they scratch pretty easily. On the first day, I had 2 deep scratches just by cleaning the screen with a microfiber. Also, the oleophobic coating can't hold a candle to glass, constantly wiping my screen. I'm using the Spigen Crystal btw. I like how on regular screen protectors, you can reinstall and get rid of dust if it gets stuck under though.
Sent from my SM-N9208 using Tapatalk
Just want to know. I have a spigen Rugged armor case that i have on right now.
I bought spigen curved crystal film and i tried to put it on but i failed so it's in the trash right now.
So right now i have a choice to just use the case and just leave it be or go to the mall and apply a zagg screen or something or buy another screen protector online.
my only concern is: i heard a lot of people say that screen protectors are not compatible with cases, so it's either one. And with the S7 edge having a "glass back" i figured a case will be more important?
Can anyone confirm? I see a lot of recommendations for cases and protectors but none of them are "in combination of" so yea.. thanks!
It's not a black and white answer.
There are slim fitting cases such as the Spigen Thin Fit, Ringke Slim, Samsung LED wallet case (note: latter I'm not sure of with TGSP, fine with TPU/PET film) which don't encroach too much on to the edges and screen area. These type of cases will work happily alongside 99% of all TGSP and traditional TPU/PET film protectors.
The more rugged cases, the type which lip round on to the screen and/or edges, these will lift or crack 99% of all TGSP or TPU/PET protectors in varying degrees of severity.
Lastly, there are a number of brands (Best Skins Ever for example) offering "case friendly" protectors. At present they're limited to TPU/PET. I've yet to see a case friendly TGSP marketed as such. These case friendly ones, whilst cannot guarantee 100% compatibility, will work with the majority of cases whether rugged or slim.
So there's your answer.
Sent from my SM-G935F using XDA-Developers mobile app
I am using the Armor Suit MilitaryShield "case cut" wet apply screen protector. I am a bit of a case junky and have 13+ cases for my S7E. The screen protector is compatible with all of the cases I own. I would prefer a tempered glass screen protector but that is largely an exercise in futility for this phone.
If you wish to achieve maximum compatibility with cases, I would recommend one that is case cut.
{
"lightbox_close": "Close",
"lightbox_next": "Next",
"lightbox_previous": "Previous",
"lightbox_error": "The requested content cannot be loaded. Please try again later.",
"lightbox_start_slideshow": "Start slideshow",
"lightbox_stop_slideshow": "Stop slideshow",
"lightbox_full_screen": "Full screen",
"lightbox_thumbnails": "Thumbnails",
"lightbox_download": "Download",
"lightbox_share": "Share",
"lightbox_zoom": "Zoom",
"lightbox_new_window": "New window",
"lightbox_toggle_sidebar": "Toggle sidebar"
}
Sent by mobile via Tapatalk
I'm using front and rear protectors (from Best Skins Ever) with the official LED case. No issues.
Edit: I take that back. The two bottom plastic corners of the case show fracture cracks after just 3 days. Brutal.
I am use glass protector for s7 edge.
Have a Nacodex tpu film (like hori protector for handheld gaming systems) and otterbox symmetry case. My girl has the same protector and has the otterbox strada case. The only protector that has lasted with these cases. Also put cheap xtreme guard protector on back. I wish someone would make a clip holster(seidio)
Sonin66 said:
Have a Nacodex tpu film (like hori protector for handheld gaming systems) and otterbox symmetry case. My girl has the same protector and has the otterbox strada case. The only protector that has lasted with these cases. Also put cheap xtreme guard protector on back. I wish someone would make a clip holster(seidio)
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
can you post pictures? and how hard is it to apply without bubbles?
I got a new edge and had to remove my old protector. This new one I have won't lay down like my first one causing all types of bubbles. All just have to reapply another but to lazy.
[/URL][/IMG]
[/URL][/IMG]
[/IMG]
TJ446 said:
I am using the Armor Suit MilitaryShield "case cut" wet apply screen protector. I am a bit of a case junky and have 13+ cases for my S7E. The screen protector is compatible with all of the cases I own. I would prefer a tempered glass screen protector but that is largely an exercise in futility for this phone.
If you wish to achieve maximum compatibility with cases, I would recommend one that is case cut.
Sent by mobile via Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This armorsuit, thus it attract lint at the edge? Used IQshield case friendly version,but it attract too much lint. How's the fingerprints resistant coating?
Now using spigen curved HD but it's easily get scratched.
Sent from my SM-G935F using XDA-Developers mobile app
squall_kay said:
This armorsuit, thus it attract lint at the edge? Used IQshield case friendly version,but it attract too much lint. How's the fingerprints resistant coating?
Now using spigen curved HD but it's easily get scratched.
Sent from my SM-G935F using XDA-Developers mobile app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Fingerprint resistance is better than most film screen protectors. Quite easy to wipe clean as well.
Lint resistance is fairly difficult to provide commentary on - I tend not to tolerate that type of thing and keep the channels between the screen and edges of whichever case I may be using (and my pockets) as clean as possible.
I will say that this screen protector dents and scratches easily, but then heals itself after a day or two. I was worried at first but then the marks gradually disappeared.
Appearance - glare is apparent and a very mild amount of orange peel. It is certainly better than Zagg. Clarity and colour reproduction is excellent.
Scroll feel is 7.8/10 verses having no screen protector. This is a necessary evil for wet screen protectors. There is a miniscule slight amount of finger drag when gliding over it.
Ease of Application - to adhere properly, you really must force yourself not to use it for awhile. I am lucky in that I have other devices I could use while the screen protector was drying. I let it dry a full 24 hours before placing it into a case. The drying time is very important for the edges to adhere properly.
Sent on mobile via Tapatalk
I have been using a $10 glass protector on my S7E for exactly a month now with the Unicorn Beettle case with one single issue.
There is a grid like pattern on the glass that is only noticeable on the Gear VR, but not at all with normal use.
My guess would be that this is somehow to keep the screen sensitivity.
I was afraid that the case would fracture the glass protector but that has not been the issue.
They work great together.
Which one is it? link?
happyantix said:
Which one is it? link?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Its from ebay. I previuosly posted about it here.
poncespr said:
I have been using a $10 glass protector on my S7E for exactly a month now with the Unicorn Beettle case with one single issue.
There is a grid like pattern on the glass that is only noticeable on the Gear VR, but not at all with normal use.
My guess would be that this is somehow to keep the screen sensitivity.
I was afraid that the case would fracture the glass protector but that has not been the issue.
They work great together.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That's the exact same case I have. I'll check that protector out as I haven't seen anyone else post saying they have a glass protector with a case like ours. Glad to see it hasn't broken since it's sandwiched.
Sent from my SM-G935V using Tapatalk
I'm using Spigen Thin Fit case together with IQShield Liquid Skin, fits well
I have a ArmorSuit full-coverage screen protector on. I also gave it a good 12 hours before use and 24 hours before en-casing.
It has fit well with the Ringke Fusion, Obliq Naked Shield, and Ghostek cases. I currently have the Ghostek on.
The Ghostek edges overlapped a bit on the top/bottom, I used a business card to smooth down the ArmorSuit under the edges and have no creep. I no gaps between the screen protector and the Ghostek case.
C0derbear said:
I have a ArmorSuit full-coverage screen protector on. I also gave it a good 12 hours before use and 24 hours before en-casing.
It has fit well with the Ringke Fusion, Obliq Naked Shield, and Ghostek cases. I currently have the Ghostek on.
The Ghostek edges overlapped a bit on the top/bottom, I used a business card to smooth down the ArmorSuit under the edges and have no creep. I no gaps between the screen protector and the Ghostek case.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Which ghostek case? Can you take a few pictures?
Sent from my SM-G935F using XDA-Developers mobile app
[email protected] said:
Which ghostek case?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Ghostek Cloak => Amazon link
I'll try to post some pics later.
I'm personally debating beetle pro full or beetle pro hybrid.. i'd like the edge protection.. i wish it had a kick stand as well.. i guess with hybrid if i go with gear vr it is easier to take off.. rumor is, though, if you cut off the two rubber bumpers on gear vr, a case (or maybe just a screen protector) will somehow fit?
The beetle pro full is apparently very hard to remove in a hurry. The hybrid lacks the edge protection.
I've already tried one tempered glass protector on amazon and it falls off or lacks sensitivity unfortunately.. seems they all have this issue.. now i'm trying to find a 100% working alternative or maybe regular type that also is good sensitivity.. 100% is probably impossible with this phone.
This Roya with kickstand case i initially got.. but its far too slippery and is falling off at times.. i'm guessing the beetle pro is the answer (full one) and just deal with it later with VR.
I searched and did not find a thread on this. I was originally going to opt in to buy the Nillkin slim case but it did not cover the bottom and top parts of the phone.... but this one does! So in case anyone is looking for a slim case, with a great feel to it that adds a bit of grip (due to the sandstone feel), this is the case for you. I have it paired with a BestSkinsEver screen protector and I have no issues with it.
{
"lightbox_close": "Close",
"lightbox_next": "Next",
"lightbox_previous": "Previous",
"lightbox_error": "The requested content cannot be loaded. Please try again later.",
"lightbox_start_slideshow": "Start slideshow",
"lightbox_stop_slideshow": "Stop slideshow",
"lightbox_full_screen": "Full screen",
"lightbox_thumbnails": "Thumbnails",
"lightbox_download": "Download",
"lightbox_share": "Share",
"lightbox_zoom": "Zoom",
"lightbox_new_window": "New window",
"lightbox_toggle_sidebar": "Toggle sidebar"
}
Can be bought here. Alternatively, I have seen it for sale on AliExpress as well.
mzkaye729 said:
I searched and did not find a thread on this. I was originally going to opt in to buy the Nillkin slim case but it did not cover the bottom and top parts of the phone.... but this one does! So in case anyone is looking for a slim case, with a great feel to it that adds a bit of grip (due to the sandstone feel), this is the case for you. I have it paired with a BestSkinsEver screen protector and I have no issues with it.
Can be bought here. Alternatively, I have seen it for sale on AliExpress as well.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Does it have a lip to protect the front screen?
markusviktorius said:
Does it have a lip to protect the front screen?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
There is, but it's minimal. Can still feel the "groove" when I run my fingers over the edges and onto the screen itself w/ my screen protector on.
mzkaye729 said:
There is, but it's minimal. Can still feel the "groove" when I run my fingers over the edges and onto the screen itself w/ my screen protector on.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I own this case and I've dropped my phone twice on a hard surface and all was well, got an orzly v2 also, I will buy another when it's a bit more worn
Is it better than Spigen ?
@mzkaye729
Can I request that you post some more close up shots of the front of the phone with the case on? I'm particularly interested in how much the lip covers the screen.
I wanted the sandstone case but couldn't justify the price that OnePlus was selling theirs for.
Thanks
Had that cover, its ok, but the only problem I had with it, when removing from pocket, it pulls my pocket out, because it sticks with it.
geekmax said:
Is it better than Spigen ?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
1) The material is different (TPU vs. hard case).
2) The slim factor is different (the Spigen case is thicker, longer, and wider).
3) The Spigen case will most likely protect more than this Pelosi case.
So if you're going for slim factor, get this case but if you want protection for your phone, I believe you're better off with the Spigen case.
simplyazn04 said:
@mzkaye729
Can I request that you post some more close up shots of the front of the phone with the case on? I'm particularly interested in how much the lip covers the screen.
I wanted the sandstone case but couldn't justify the price that OnePlus was selling theirs for.
Thanks
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'll try and take some pictures tonight and upload them so you can see (unless someone gets to do this first before I can).
What is your opinion on the BestSkinsEver screen protector? Is it similar to a regular PET screen protector? How good is the oleophobic coating on it and the translucency of it compared to the stock or third-party screen protectors?
simplyazn04 said:
@mzkaye729
Can I request that you post some more close up shots of the front of the phone with the case on? I'm particularly interested in how much the lip covers the screen.
I wanted the sandstone case but couldn't justify the price that OnePlus was selling theirs for.
Thanks
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Here you go.
EVR_PR said:
What is your opinion on the BestSkinsEver screen protector? Is it similar to a regular PET screen protector? How good is the oleophobic coating on it and the translucency of it compared to the stock or third-party screen protectors?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I am a little biased because I have installed BSE protectors on electronics/phones I have owned, as long as BSE offers the option to as I think it is a fantastic product (good value for the money, shipping is extremely cheap to Toronto, Canada). It's not the same as a regular PET screen protector. I think you're talking about those plastic protectors but I find those scratch easily, and also, the application is different. I have yet to put a deep or noticeable scratch on a BSE skin but again, this depends on how you handle the phones/electronics. I even have this BSE skin on my Pebble watch and that thing takes a beating. Still no scratches visible on the screen protector itself on the watch.
I don't believe there's any oleophobic coating at all on the BSE skin, and if there is, super minimal that I don't even notice it ? With that said, I don't think it's fair for me to comment on the "oleophobic coating" (or maybe lack thereof) because I don't typically handle my phone if I have handled (oily) food. With regular use, I don't notice much fingerprints so it's not something that has jumped out at me.
I have had no issues with yellowing, and the "orange peel" look is VERY VERY minimal compared to something like XtremeGuard (the yellowing issue/orange peel was horrible on that). I had this BSE on my Note 4; had no issue with the S-pen gliding on it. The glossy screen protector from BSE won't cut into the clarity of the phone's display so that's not something to worry about. I have tried glass screen protectors and OK, maybe you can tell side-by-side the difference in clarity by a little bit, but typically, the glass protectors are used for drop protection. I prefer the BSE because the fingerprints on the glass bother me, and my main concern are scratches on the screen, not a shattered screen *knock on wood*.
mzkaye729 said:
Here you go.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thank you so much for taking time out of your day to post this.
Looks like it offers very little protection on the front side though so I will be sticking with my Spigen Rugged. If only this phone was more popular, manufacturers would make more cases. I get jealous of iPhones for having all the cool phone cases.
Thanks again!
Hey everyone,
I really don't know what happened lately but suddenly choosing a screen protector is harder than choosing a phone
I came across 3 fairly dominant companies and would like a more personal opinion from you.
1) Skinomi TechSkin/MatteSkin
2) IQ Shield Liquid Shield/Matte
3) Spigen Neo Flex
All 3 are considered "case-friendly", although from what I have heard, they all don't go very well with the Otterbox Defender, which is what I'm planning to have, but correct me if you know otherwise.
Questions:
1) Which one would you consider to be the best one? Are you experienced with any of them?
2) Both Skinomi and IQ Shield have a "version 2" screen protector. Does anyone know what is the difference between version 1 and 2?
3) I'm a HUGE fan of Matte screen protectors, I just love the feel and the anti-fingerprint. The only downside to it is a bit of a blurry feel in the screen. If any of you tried their Matte protectors, how bad is that blur?
Thank you,
Omga4000
edit: thought you were looking for tempered glass, but looks like you're looking for a screen protector
twistanesh said:
edit: thought you were looking for tempered glass, but looks like you're looking for a screen protector
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I wasn't able to catch what you wrote before the edit, but any opinion is good!
The problem with Tempered Glass is that there is only 1 company which makes a "full adhesive" solution, Whitestone.
From what I have read - they are really not that great, and do not support the Otterbox Defender series.
If you know something else, please do share
IQ Shield and Skinomi are better than the Spigen and all three are better than Ringke. Version 1 and 2 differentiate between the cutoff points for case friendliness. Ver 1 of the IQ Shield ends before the screen of the Note 8 ends which means a tiny part of the screen will be unprotected on the sides. Version 2 covers the whole visible screen and works for some cases. Version 1 works with basically all cases, but it gives you slightly less protection due to it being "most case friendly" of all.
You're going to get graininess from the matte protectors, that's just the name of the game.
I have had success with the IQ Shield. No peeling and relatively smooth for a soft TPU.
Kawaisa said:
I have had success with the IQ Shield. No peeling and relatively smooth for a soft TPU.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Perfect, that works for me.
Ordered both the Version 1 and Version 2 of IQ Shield (Matte). I hope that version 2 will fit the Otterbox, though I doubt it.
Thank you
I had the spigen neo flex on my s8 and went with the skinomi techskin on my note 8 based on amazon reviews. Just installed it last night, super easy and haven't noticed any issues. I'm using it with a spigen neo hybrid case and all my edges are flat on the screen. Any streaks or air bubbles left cured over night. Highly recommend.
Sent from my SM-N950U using XDA-Developers Legacy app
Spigen Note 8 screen protector on wife's Note 8. Can you say orange peel galore?
{
"lightbox_close": "Close",
"lightbox_next": "Next",
"lightbox_previous": "Previous",
"lightbox_error": "The requested content cannot be loaded. Please try again later.",
"lightbox_start_slideshow": "Start slideshow",
"lightbox_stop_slideshow": "Stop slideshow",
"lightbox_full_screen": "Full screen",
"lightbox_thumbnails": "Thumbnails",
"lightbox_download": "Download",
"lightbox_share": "Share",
"lightbox_zoom": "Zoom",
"lightbox_new_window": "New window",
"lightbox_toggle_sidebar": "Toggle sidebar"
}
Sent from my SM-N950U using Tapatalk
I can attest to the quality of the Skinomi TechSkin. It's great, and somehow it protected by screen from a good fall on some rocks when I launched my phone in the air getting out of my car as I forgot it was in my lap. Put a bunch of dents in the protector but my screen was fine. May have been a fluke.
Otherwise, it's a wet application and can be a bit aggravating, especially getting the sides the stick, but eventually they do. It looks HORRIBLE for the first 24 hours or so, but all the bubbles dissappear and you can't tell it's even on.
My only complaint is the S Pen gouges it pretty bad, but it's really only noticeable in direct light or with the screen off.
Edit: also I believe I got version 2, it fit with every case I own, and I have quite a few.
Does either of the matte skins for the ringke onyx?
Thank you ?
Best note 8 PET Protector (Easy ULT)
I found this one to be the best combination of coverage, Feel and works with the S Pen without leaving lines or too much drag. They dont do a case friendly version but i cut the sides down 2mm either side and re cut the radius on the corners
2 pack]Samsung Note 8 Screen Protector, EasyULT 2 Pack PET Screen Protectors for Samsung Note 8 (HD Ultra Clear Film,Full Coverage) avaliable on Amazon.
sorry cant post link.
Omga4000 said:
The problem with Tempered Glass is that there is only 1 company which makes a "full adhesive" solution, Whitestone.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I trust by now there is another alternative. I'm looking for a full adhesive solution as I don't feel comfortable with a protector that only adheres to the edges leaving an air bubble in the middle of the screen.
Whitestone Fail
I tried the Whitestone and it didn't go too well. Got bubbles under the screen protector on the first and second try. The adhesive ran all over - down into the speaker holes, in the S-Pen slot, earphone jack, charger port......it was a complete disaster.
Me and a couple of friends are using the Samsung official screen protector for S8+ and they're great. They will heal very fast from pen mark
Ionakr said:
They will heal very fast from pen mark
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That must mean that it is "soft" and not be able to withstand shatter tests (for accidental drops), nor any direct impacts to the screen by sharp objects.
As much as I prefer tempered glass, I've given up on my search for a TG protector that fits, looks and feels right.
That being said, I'm now on the hunt for a wet application screen protector that offers the closest thing to edge-to-edge coverage as possible. I use an Elago case when I'm out and no case as all when home, so case-friendly is of no benefit to me.
Thanks in advance for your recommendations, shared personal experiences and pictures (if any)!
IQ Shield, full screen version
https://www.amazon.com/Protector-LiQuidSkin-Coverage-Maximum-Anti-Bubble/dp/B07576CPTZ
The problem with the wet ones is the pen leaves marked and not smooth
I have had the Spigen and the Skinomi. The Spigen one is very thick and always has an orange peel look to is. I have had the Skinomi V1 which fits with most cases and now have the Skinomi V2 which is more edge to edge. The Skinomi 'heals' a lot faster than the Spigen - yes it leaves pen marks but use the black tip and just wait a few, they do go away. The Skinomi is thinner and is very smooth so it doesn't have that orange peel look.
The V2 only fits with minimal cases, I have a Pitaka and it fits perfectly edge to edge of the glass. I had a Skinomi on my Note 7 and loved it, the only reason I started with the Spigen is that the Skinomi wasn't available at the time. At 2 for $7 on Amazon, it's hard to beat. Easy to apply and I do them super wet to allow for the best alignment. Added bonus, they do hide minor chips and cracks very well.
Skinomi V2 for Note 8 (excuse the pocket dust). I tried to show the most extreme angles and worst aspects, looking straight on it's perfectly clear.
{
"lightbox_close": "Close",
"lightbox_next": "Next",
"lightbox_previous": "Previous",
"lightbox_error": "The requested content cannot be loaded. Please try again later.",
"lightbox_start_slideshow": "Start slideshow",
"lightbox_stop_slideshow": "Stop slideshow",
"lightbox_full_screen": "Full screen",
"lightbox_thumbnails": "Thumbnails",
"lightbox_download": "Download",
"lightbox_share": "Share",
"lightbox_zoom": "Zoom",
"lightbox_new_window": "New window",
"lightbox_toggle_sidebar": "Toggle sidebar"
}
Thanks for the input so far!
very happy with my screen protector from tech21.
I have used Armoursuit wet protector on my s7 edge and this Note 8....perfect install both times....never peeled up from edge...covers sides...and will work with case friendly...I have used pen and no marks on screen so far
Watch install video and use hair dryer to assist.
No other reason for me to get anything else..
Good luck
Had good luck with the Skinomi so far , works good with s pen. Just ordered an Armorsuit to try them out as well. Have used Armorsuit in the past with good results as well.
Sent from my Galaxy Note8 using XDA Labs
I went with the IQ Shield and I'm pretty happy with it. I'm actually not noticing any pen marks. Perhaps I'm not pressing as hard as others.
Does any one know if the IQ shield interfere with the samsung clearview official stand/case ?
Skinomi case friendly version 2 ???
oarenj said:
I have had the Spigen and the Skinomi. The Spigen one is very thick and always has an orange peel look to is. I have had the Skinomi V1 which fits with most cases and now have the Skinomi V2 which is more edge to edge. The Skinomi 'heals' a lot faster than the Spigen - yes it leaves pen marks but use the black tip and just wait a few, they do go away. The Skinomi is thinner and is very smooth so it doesn't have that orange peel look.
The V2 only fits with minimal cases, I have a Pitaka and it fits perfectly edge to edge of the glass. I had a Skinomi on my Note 7 and loved it, the only reason I started with the Spigen is that the Skinomi wasn't available at the time. At 2 for $7 on Amazon, it's hard to beat. Easy to apply and I do them super wet to allow for the best alignment. Added bonus, they do hide minor chips and cracks very well.
Skinomi V2 for Note 8 (excuse the pocket dust). I tried to show the most extreme angles and worst aspects, looking straight on it's perfectly clear.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I see you have that bad ass case on.:laugh: mine is coming in monday I can not wait. Also I am getting the car mount with it.
Did anyone try the Armorsuite full body protector? Can you wonder around with it only and no cases?
After trying a lot of protectors and losing too much money. Nillkin TG is perfect in covering the whole screen with angles, it has black edges, compatible with all cases and the most important thing is that the sensitivity to touch is outstanding!
Sent from my [device_name] using XDA-Developers Legacy app
try the Techmatte Tempered Glass. probably the best on both the S8 Plus and Note 8, and I have both phones.
Sent from my SM-N950U1 using XDA-Developers Legacy app
I gave up on glass screen protectors with curved screens. I can't stand the lip it leaves on the edges. Especially since I use multiple apps that I have to swipe from the edge. I have been using the Nano liquid screen protectors and don't have any scratches. Now I know it will not help if I drop my phone on its face. But something you just have to deal with. I did see this one called from simply carbon it's a flexible screen protector that you can hit with a hammer and it will not break. Has anyone tried one of these?
I put the Skinomi 2 on last night
I've never done a wet-application screen protector before and it was surprisingly easy. Today the bubbles are all gone except for one little dust spec that doesn't bother me. It works well with my new Spigen Tough Armor case. I'm happy with this combo
jason504 said:
I gave up on glass screen protectors with curved screens. I can't stand the lip it leaves on the edges. Especially since I use multiple apps that I have to swipe from the edge. I have been using the Nano liquid screen protectors and don't have any scratches. Now I know it will not help if I drop my phone on its face. But something you just have to deal with. I did see this one called from simply carbon it's a flexible screen protector that you can hit with a hammer and it will not break. Has anyone tried one of these?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I just looked up the Simply Carbon Fiber screen protectors. Looks interesting. I just wonder if they are soft and the S-Pen will leave leave marks or not. They also don't look to be case friendly.
Mr. Orange 645 said:
I just looked up the Simply Carbon Fiber screen protectors. Looks interesting. I just wonder if they are soft and the S-Pen will leave leave marks or not. They also don't look to be case friendly.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That's the same thing I was thinking too. Because I love how smooth the glass is on my Note8 I don't want anything that doesn't feel like that.
Sent from my SM-N950U using Tapatalk
jason504 said:
That's the same thing I was thinking too. Because I love how smooth the glass is on my Note8 I don't want anything that doesn't feel like that.
Sent from my SM-N950U using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm currently using a wer apply screen protector. It feels smooth and looks great, but the S-Pen leaves marks. Theres just no perfect solution.